Reviews for Old Mill Pub

06/08/2025 - Crystal M.
The friendly staff and warm atmosphere make this bar a welcoming place to enjoy excellent food like fish and chips, Philly cheesesteak, chicken panini, and especially the wings, which I believe are the best in the Poconos. With large portions, good drinks, lively music, and a great outdoor deck, it's a fantastic spot to relax, whether you're staying nearby or just passing through.

08/30/2024 - Sharon I.
The barmaid was very friendly, the food was great, and the atmosphere was welcoming, making it worth the drive.

04/27/2024 - Erika E.
Appetizing

03/02/2021 - MenuPix User
Good clean place with good food and great staff tryn to survive thru all of the present day challenges and unfathomable rules in place stop by and enjoy the atmosphere with open mic nights on Tuesdays

02/05/2021 - Steve
Driven past this place for 2 years and never stopped. Finally decided to give it a try and boy have I been missing out for years! The food is amazing, the atmosphere is quiet and relaxed, staff and customers are all super friendly, prices are very fair, and there's live music, deck seating, and other perks that the average passerby are completely unaware of! It's a local joint but it's always these quaint places that are impressive. It's my new home away from home. I recommend anyone stop in and try it.