Reviews for Tony's Pizza & Subs

09/30/2019 - MenuPix User
I would give no stars but the bagged chips were good. The absolute worst cheesesteak I have ever had and I am 60! It was ordered with mushrooms and onions. I could not find many of either and certainly could not taste them. I called and talked to manager Josh and he said if I come in when he is there he will make me one personally. Huh, shouldn't all the cooks make a sandwich with "stuff" actually on it? Should I try to find out when he is there and move my schedule around that to get a good sub? BS!!!! Spend your money elsewhere, not worth it.

08/23/2016 - Nick C.
Terrible pizza. I mistakenly went there with my wife looking for Tony's New York Style Pizzeria on Orchard Park Dr. in Greenville. I made an error when using Google for the directions which led us to this sub-par pizza spot. The place was empty - that should have been the first sign. We ordered the "cheesy bread" which was basically a plain pizza and a medium meat lovers pizza. Both the appetizer and the pizza were embarrassing and disgraceful when categorized as Italian food. My wife and I would have been better off buying a frozen pizza from the grocery store - it was that bad. Our waitress was nice - the only ray of hope we had through the dining experience until she made us go up to the counter to pay the check to settle up which was really odd considering we were eating in their dining room and had been serviced by waitstaff through the earlier portion of the meal. Greenville is a great food city, avoid this place at all costs. No doubt, you'll be disappointed.

12/27/2011 - Peyton
Pizza is YUM!And so are the prices!:)