Reviews for Papa Piccione's Pizza

04/18/2024 - Martha J.
Good stuff

01/19/2024 - MenuPix User

10/29/2021 - Gayle
10/28/21
I did a take out order. I ordered a olive burger deluxe basket. Since when do you put dill pickles on a olive burger?? Dumb!
A sliced tomato and leaf lettuce would have been 100% better than chopped up lettuce and tomatoes. Couldnt taste the cheese either. Throw in some Cole slaw, and the price wouldn't have hurt so bad, almost $13.00. WOW
One thing for sure the burger patty itself was very delicious, as the frys.
I've been promised several times from Tim Sabin, the owner, compensated for several other orders I made, burnt cauliflower, burnt chicken wings, burger came with no bun, items missing etc, but never received any such compensation. When am I ever going to learn not to order from them??? Money is in short supply on SS, but I was keeping it my community. NO MORE, I'M DONE WITH PAPA PICCIONES!

09/24/2021 - Ben
Delicious food!

06/24/2021 - rontheharleyman
Always a great place to eat

05/13/2021 - MenuPix User
Cold uncut green olive on taco pizza

09/15/2020 - Julie
We enjoy the food.

04/28/2020 - MenuPix User
We ordered 2 different burritos and could not tell which one was which since they weren’t marked. When I called you could hear the employees arguing about the order.
The burritos also had a very heavy salt taste.
The worst burritos we have ever had

03/29/2020 - Jeff VW
Great food, great owners. Jeff is a leader in the community, and always looking for ways to give back. Best pizza in northern Kent County!!

02/03/2019 - Gayle Fisk
Food is excellent . Owners are great 👍. But last night Feb 2, I ordered delivery, which was great , but the deluxe cheeseburger 🍔I ordered had NO cheese on it, NO condiments , diced tomatoes and diced onions, prefer sliced, and NO pickles!! what happened?? It was very very dry trying to eat it. The meat itself was delicious😋. I was disappointed. 😞The French fries 🍟were superb.😋 I definitely will order again but check the food for correct order.

10/09/2014 - Chris
This place has the best food! Best burgers, best burritos, and of course best pizza. The staff is always friendly and the owners go above and beyond helping out with the community

06/25/2013 - Brian Johnson
the food is not very good either is the managment. I will never spend another dollar in this place.