Reviews for Aileen's Cake Decor

04/14/2025 - MenuPix User
I contacted this bakery in October over email with a quote inquiry and to see if they were capable of doing this cake-- they promptly responsed saying they were capable of doing this cake for a reasonable price for the original 100 guests (~~$730). I was excited and told them I needed to discuss it with my Fiancí© and we were still solidifying the guest list so we would be in contact when we had a better idea of the amount of people, and that my wedding was 6 months away. (A groomsman recommended this bakery, so we were going to go with them because of my fiance).

November, December, I attempted contact over 5 times-- to request an updated quote with a new guest amount of 180, no response each time. I finally got frustrated and decided to go in person. They told me that the person who did the quotes was out, but if I put my deposit down, and started my file, they GUARANTEED a call tomorrow morning with the estimate. So, they took a $350 deposit, and assured me they would call The Next Morning GUARANTEE 💯.

The next morning, no call. The next week... no call or contact....

I got so frustrated and upset, I went online and looked up cake tier sizes and Serving amounts MYSELF, and sent ANOTHER email saying, Just give me a price quote for this cake tiering with lemon cake, rasberry filling and buttercream frosting.

They immediately emailed me back with the quote of $1824...... from $730 to $1824.....

That's a 150% increase, and their reasoning was, "we charge be the Serving size".

Instead of having the "250 servings" They said their cake would serve, we had only about 80 guests attended..... this cake WOULD NOT HAVE SERVED an additional 100 guests....

Let alone, the audacity of the "Capabilities" of matching the reference cake-- They INSISTED AND disregarded my requests each time I brought up my preference for a buttercream instead of fondant. I HATE FONDANT-- they said the flowers and decorations wouldn't hold on buttercream...they didn't color match the burgundy, the gold was yellow, the flowers were fake and the other fake decorations were attached with sticks (so they could have been used in buttercream), the "piping design" was a single pressed on stamp of block frosting IN the wrong location by itself on the side towards the back of the cake like an after thought, the rasberry filling was BARELY there, and when we cut and separated the cake layers the cake crumbled apart.

This was THE WORST part of EVERYTHING!!

I even think in the contract they were so cheap to put in that they were to get their fake flower decorations returned...

What a joke! Never recommending this bakery to anyone!

01/16/2025 - Carl R.
The cake shop in Pueblo exceeded all my expectations for my wedding cake. Aileen and her team were incredibly accommodating, and the cake itself was a work of art that tasted even better than it looked. They truly saved the day for my daughter's birthday with a beautifully crafted cake that was both affordable and delicious.

07/07/2024 - Super H.
best around

07/19/2020 - Susan Kimes
Aileen's did our wedding cakes three years ago and my husband's birthday cakes. She makes the best mocha cake ever! Getting ready to order another for his birthday this month!