Reviews for Gondolier Italian Restaurant

04/15/2025 - Kayla T.
The breadsticks and sauce at Gondolier are fantastic, and the pizza is consistently delicious with generous portions. While the initial greeting could be warmer, the overall dining experience, including the attentive service and tasty food, makes it a great choice for Italian and Greek cuisine.

03/10/2025 - Kennedy R.
Delicious breadsticks and sauce greet you the moment you step inside, setting the tone for an inviting experience. The pizza, with its generous toppings and quality crust, never fails to satisfy after a long journey. While the communication at the entrance could use some warmth, the overall food and ambiance create a lovely atmosphere perfect for family gatherings.

05/03/2024 - Madison M.
Great Food Excellent Service

10/24/2022 - MenuPix User
We had takeout. The baked spaghetti with meat sauce was watery, very little meat sauce. The cheese was melted but seemed to be microwaved, not baked. Did not enjoy at all. Bread sticks were good but were cramed onto bag and broken. The chicken Alfredo tasted like tv dinner, was also watery. The hot wings were awesome. Very poor experience.

02/13/2021 - Darlene
The best pizza since i left NW indiana. Plus other dishes are amazing too

07/26/2020 - mikey
great food great service

11/23/2018 - tom myers
Great pizza!!!!

04/13/2013 - Bonnie Mayo
Loved the food it was great and the service was terrific. We go often.

07/09/2010 - unsatisfied
Awful! I called in a pick-up order and went to pick it up. I was walking in my front door when the manager called to inform me that they had failed to put all of my family's food in the bag. Then, she proceeded to lie to me saying that she ran out after me when I exited the restaurant. I find this hard to believe since I stood by my vehicle rearranging my wallet and purse for a moment. I had to drive back to be treated rudely. The manager could be seen through the kitchen door playing "conductor" with spatulas but was "too busy" to help me when I came back or to speak with me when I called. When I asked her name or the owner's name, I received the reply, "I don't know." Awful service! We will never be returning. If I wanted to be treated rudely, I certainly wouldn't have paid for it.