Reviews for Coney Island Bar

08/19/2025 - Mark T.
The Coney Island Bar, an authentic old-school Reno/Sparks Italian family-owned restaurant housed in a 1930s building under a freeway overpass, serves fantastic, reasonably portioned dishes like lasagna, spaghetti, pastrami, and corned beef with cabbage, offers a daily changing menu with excellent service from friendly staff in a nostalgic, welcoming atmosphere filled with regular locals, making every meal-from their killer hot pastrami sandwich to the epic bread pudding-a surprising and memorable experience despite occasional challenges with parking and menu availability.

02/20/2025 - Ted C.
The Coney Island Bar blew me away with its incredible food and welcoming atmosphere, which reminded me of a nostalgic diner from the 70s. Initially unsure about the dive-like exterior, I was pleasantly surprised by the outstanding lasagna and roast chicken, making it a hidden treasure that I can't wait to revisit with friends and family.