Reviews for Schuyler Bakery

08/07/2025 - Kevin K.
The bakery offers a variety of classic baked goods, including seasonal pumpkin and apple cider donuts, Italian rainbow cookies, and their well-loved cheese danish. The nut-free facility provides friendly service and consistently delicious items like their famous double-glazed Paczkis, paska bread, and buttercream cakes, making it a reliable choice for special occasions. Though the interior is simple and the selection limited compared to larger bakeries, the quality, reasonable prices, and old-fashioned charm make it worth visiting again.

01/19/2025 - Laura H.
This bakery offers a fantastic selection of treats, including pumpkin and apple cider donuts that are perfect for the season. Their cheese danish is absolutely delicious and worth a try! The Italian rainbow cookies are a must-have, and the glaze donuts are truly exceptional. The staff is friendly and helpful, making the whole experience even better. I can't wait to go back and indulge in more of their delectable offerings.

06/07/2023 - MenuPix User
This bakery has gone downhill since new owner took over. Not like it used to be. Go in for certain favorites and there is never any. Terrible. I'll continue to go to Bella Napoli

01/17/2023 - Bob Roark
I always love their old fashioned donuts I've been going there since the '60s but when it was sold at first the old-fashioned donuts for fried too much but today I stopped and rolling behold donuts are back to being delicious and just like they were 60 years ago

08/21/2021 - Dave
This bakery is like going back in Time As soon as you go through the door you smell the fresh bakery cookies cookies donuts birthday cakes wedding cakes sugar buns add wonderful Danish.. I cannot recommend this place enough place enough the prices are fair And the food is delicious just like your Grandmother wanted it please give them a try you'll be back for More.

11/19/2020 - Joann
My family has been going here for 40 years. Excellent baked goods at a reasonable price. Everything is fresh and delicious.

03/14/2020 - Joanie
X can I get you're recipe for sugar buns. I live in Fl and no one even knows what a NY sugar bun is.