Reviews for Goodfellas

01/17/2024 - MenuPix User

01/01/2024 - MenuPix User

04/02/2017 - Valerie
I do not care to hear what other people say; especially when they have awful things to say. Good Fellas is exceptionally excellent. people do not understand that every body taste buds are different. Stick with what taste good to you. The food is good and also the service. I will always return and bring friends with me to dine. You rock Good Fellas; keep up the good work.

02/06/2017 - terrible
OMG
SO BAD
PRIME RIB WAS SO TOUGH AND COLD. BAKED POTATO WAS REHEATED. TASTE LIKE GLUE
WON'T GO BACK
SO BAD
I FELT SORRY FOR THE WAITRESS

07/09/2016 - Whitney
Never again will I go back!!!!!!!

12/08/2015 - kate
we have had company parties there for like 4 years food was great service was great it was company so i paid nothing ,,,


we also ate there about 4 months ago ? dinner was really good service was good it was pouring ,,, it wasnt real expensive .. i didnt get charged for a coffee cup of hot water like i did at out back in williamsburg .. NO i didnt have a tea bag ,, i drink hot water with dinner ,, outback i paid 2.79 ... i didnt at good fellas ... no complaints ,,

07/07/2015 - Not a good choice
The food isn't that great- especially the seafood. Red Lobster is way better! The service was terrible. The chocolate cake was dry and definitely was not homemade. To top it off, the restaurant made another charge of $0.07 on my credit card. That made me very suspicious!

06/08/2015 - Carolyn
PLEASE DO NOT EAT HERE. WASTED $100.00 . HORRIBLE. GOT SICK THE MOMENT I GOT HOME! PEPTO ALL NIGHT. THIS WAS THE SECOND TIME I GOT SICK. I THOUGHT..... EH, I WILL GIVE IT ANOTHER CHANCE AFTER MY FIRST EXPERIENCE, STUPID STUPID MOVE ON MY PART

04/01/2015 - Mrs Messick
Took my mother there for her 80th birthday my husband had veal Parmesan the veal was hard and tough you couldn't cut it the spaghetti noodles were tough you couldn't chew it I ordered stuff shrimp and had four tiny shrimp and 3 tablespoons of white rice and a little tiny bit of crab meat inside the shrimp and a baked potato that was left over from the day before they also were out of several items and didn't substitute for the platters the food overall was very bad

03/23/2015 - Heather S.
While my family was eating at my son's birthday dinner, I ordered the alfredo with shrimp. After four bites, I felt something in my mouth. When I spit out the foreign object, it was something either a two inch long small fish skeleton or bug body. When I confronted the manager, she was less than apologetic, but more irritated at me for finding this in the dish. She stated that she had taken a picture of the item as I had and could contact the health department. Really? Instead of apologizing, she was angry at me! Seriously, I would NEVER eat there again 1- for the foreign body 2 - because of the attitude I received from the manager

03/18/2015 - phil
I have visited this restaurant many times in the last 10 years about 1 year ago the service was horrible we came back a second time same waiter same horrible service never again

09/06/2014 - Joe
How do you call yourself a steak house with only two steaks advertised

04/10/2014 - Mary Harris
Great for families as well as a night out! They serve fresh local seafood, steaks and homemade pasta dishes! The kids menu is great for those of age and nightly specials are always delicious!