Reviews for Lefty's Pizza

05/20/2020 - MenuPix User
Great pizza! Best in the area. Haven’t ever ordered anything else there. Why would I? :)

02/23/2018 - Dawn
FYI, there are two Lefty's in Amelia. The original one is quite good, especially if you order the everything pizza.

05/13/2017 - Nancy P.
Only restaurant open on Monday night in Amelia. Worse spaghetti we have ever had. Asked for small size $7.95. Asked for baked (cheese on top) and meat sauce. Waitress said I can give you ground beef, so we said ok. That was $7.95 for spaghetti, $2 for cheese, $2 for ground beef. Husband wanted cheese $2, ground beef $2, mushrooms $2 and sausage $2. Of course we did not know every add on was $2. And it was awful. Ground beef was fake beef that look like little pellets and tasted nothing like ground beef. No sauce at all -- just dried spaghetti with tomatoes on top of it and cheese on top plus husbands other add ons. Ended up very expensive meal that was almost uneatable. Never going there again. .

12/02/2015 - REC & SO
We are from the Richmond area.
Best pizza I have had in a loooong time. I read the bad review; fancy pizzas come with toppings some do not like, so tell them to leave them off. That is what I do, unless I forget, then it is my fault and I deal with it. We; myself & SO, bought pizza, a steak sub, and lasagna. All the food was great, the service was pleasant, thoughtful, and attentive. I did not try the sub, but my GF said it was incredible. Next time I am anywhere near Amelia, I am stopping by to get a pizza. I could give a list of great pizzas in Richmond; this place in the country matches or beats Richmond's best. Sorta like the Front Porch restaurant in Seneca, WV.

08/11/2015 - Suzanne lenhart
I ordered a supreme pizza when we got home found the restaurant had placed anchovies on it. Called the restaurant and was told by the girl who took my order that all their supreme pizza come this way and you have to tell them not to put the anchovies on it. One, no other pizza place will do this and they always ask first and second I have other friends that go in there and they do have to ask for it to be added. So the girl who answered the phone messed up and they were unwilling to do anything for me and I ended up throwing a large pizza away. Will always talk bad about this restaurant and tell everyone not to go there.