Reviews for Costello's

01/29/2024 - MenuPix User

11/01/2023 - MenuPix User

07/20/2019 - Mary Beth
We had a luncheon there for about 35 people. Food was ordered in advance and was ready when we arrived and it was wonderful. All who were there commented on the delicious meal. The staff took good care of us and were very attentive. Couldn't ask for a better venue for our luncheon. Thank you, Costello's!

04/19/2018 - Stu
The review here was old so I thought I’d add and updated one.

We dropped in the other evening with our 2 granddaughters. We were using a get my perk coupon which is a great way to try a new place. This is one of the places we will return to. Someone mentioned the cost of drinks. Yes $2.50 for a soda seems high (I complain sometimes about that sometimes too) but it’s about average for anywhere decent. Check out what you’re paying at a fast food restaurant next time you’re there. Drinks aren’t cheap there either. You can’t compare restaurant prices to a 2 liter bottle you take home.

As for the food, we ordered a pizza and a chicken wing stromboli The price was fair and both were larger than I had expected. In fact, I would have to say that the stromboli they brought out was quite possibly the largest portion of any restaurant item I can remember receiving.

It filled a 16 inch pizza tray and was pre-cut into 8 or 10 very large pieces. We ate all we wanted there and there was a lunch or 2 to take with us along with a couple slices of pizza we didn’t finish.

The service was just a little slow but little enough price to pay for a very clean looking upscale feeling place for dinner.

07/26/2014 - Dan
We had a group of six attend a sit down dinner. The wait staff was very attentive. The various corses cam within a reasonable after the previous curse and the food was hot and tasty. The prices were very reasonable. Kudos to the owners and staff.

05/11/2014 - joe s.
Went for mother's day. They told us 20 bucks per person and lied about what was on the buffet. When i got the bill for 6 adults and 2 kids under 6 was $190. We thought it was a little steep for what we got. They overcharged for all the beverages to jack up the bill. The desert table was a disgrace. They had peel and eat shrimp by the salad in a very small plate as to say "only take a few. We also paid an 18% service charge. (Which we did expect) . All in all for the money we paid it was quite disappointing.