Reviews for Dicarlo Brothers Pizza

02/23/2025 - Justine S.
The Buffalo Chicken pizza is the best I've ever tasted, and I could eat it daily. With consistent quality for over thirty years, friendly employees, reasonable prices, and a standout buffalo chicken calzone, this restaurant never disappoints.

07/02/2024 - Alissa F.
Nice place good food

08/14/2023 - will
Got 4 slices Thursday 8/10/23. The pizza was re heats. Hard as a rock. Will not go there anymore.

03/24/2023 - Raymond
Just simply great tasting and fresh.

07/18/2019 - MenuPix User
I would give them 5 stars if they accepted Credit or Debit Cards. Has a ATM machine which charges a fee for getting cash. Only Place in Follansbee that I know of that doesn't accept cards

06/03/2018 - Larry
Fav pizza place in WV. They always cook in just perfect.

10/23/2015 - Jessica C
While the food is good. The company refused to remake a delivery order after only delivering 1/2 of it. Why would only 1/2 of my family want to eat, while the other 1/2 watches. If we waited for the other 1/2 to come then everything would be cold. It only seemed logical for them to remake the order and take the food they already brought back with them. I wasn't looking for anything free, just what I had already paid for.