Reviews for Mario's NY Style Pizza

03/23/2024 - MenuPix User

02/17/2024 - MenuPix User

01/30/2024 - MenuPix User

01/27/2024 - MenuPix User

12/27/2023 - MenuPix User

11/30/2023 - MenuPix User

01/10/2022 - Rob
excellent pizza, also other menu items are very good. eaten there numerous times never disappointed. only small complaint wait time after place order. Don’t understand bad reviews?

08/12/2019 - George
Great Pizza! Loved every bite. Wait time was average and the price was fair. I mean it is not “Little Caesar’s”, you get what you pay for. I have an office in Mannington and am so glad they’re here

02/12/2015 - Janette
My husband and I have eaten at this restaurant quite a few times and the food and the staff have always been great. I highly recommend the meatball sliders and French fries. Their blackberry cobbler ala mode is delicious. They also have a superb liver and onion entree if you like that type of meal. We have never had a bad experience eating here thus far. I was surprised to see the bad reviews and felt compelled to give them a good one. They deserve it!

01/21/2015 - mason
the food is nasty not real Italian food the hung up on me and i had to call back with my address i will never order food from this place again

04/24/2014 - chynna
it pisses me off that they don't deliver. the price is out rageus and maybe the price they have for walk in should be delivery.

07/11/2011 - Billie Everly
This is NOT authentic Italian food. The food is awful and you don't get very much for the price. One of the employees was actually spray painting the ceiling over part of the kitchen while we were there. I couldn't believe it. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive. She was the only good thing about this dump.

03/21/2010 - John
Food isn't very good for the price. I ordered my food at 4:05 and they said it would be here in 20 minuets at around 5:10 I called them back and asked where my order was. They said yeah the delivery guy just left. I finally got my meal at 5:35 then I looked out the window and the man who delivered my food was driving the wrong way on our 1 way street. My house is only 2 miles away so I know it wasn't the drive that took so long.

12/02/2009 - Georgina
Their food is amazing, but it takes FOREVER to get your food. If you get lucky you may end up with a nice waitress, but the majority of them are just rude. Their prices are also kind of high and they raise their prices and cut down on portions. But, if you have a day when you can devote about two hours and devote some cash, then this resteraunt is the way to go. They do actually have italian employees and their food is good and it is authentic italian.

04/01/2009 - MenuPix User
Decent food but the employees are so rude it takes away from the Tradional Old Time Italian food aspect. Some of the costs are silly such as being charged 50 cents for two packets of ketchup but if you have plenty of cash and a high tolerance for people this is your place