Reviews for Castle Hill Supper Club

06/24/2025 - Kennedy Z.
Driving through the quiet countryside, the warm glow inside invited us to step into a comforting world of classic Wisconsin supper club charm. The prime rib arrived perfectly cooked, its tender richness paired with buttery mushrooms and a baked potato that felt like a warm embrace on a cool evening. Sipping on a smooth brandy old fashioned while surrounded by friendly faces and a cozy, family-like atmosphere made this an unforgettable stop on our journey.

06/04/2024 - Sydnie N.
love it

05/21/2024 - Shar I.
A friend from the area recommended this place to us, and we were pleasantly surprised by the cozy small town vibe of this supper club. The menu had a variety of food options at reasonable prices, and the atmosphere was family-friendly with plenty of seating. We enjoyed our meal and will definitely consider stopping by again on our next trip between Madison and the Twin Cities.

09/10/2022 - MenuPix User
Just called about the prime rib sat meal. Man who answered was very very rude. Have never been there but for sure will not make the drive now.