Reviews for Jim's Pizzeria

07/22/2024 - Te A.
One of the best pizzas in town, worth every penny. The secret sauce they use is absolutely addictive. The service may be a bit slow, but the quality of the pizza makes it all worth it. The ownership is phenomenal, and the friendly staff truly make the experience memorable. If you're looking for the best pizza in Wisconsin, this is the place to be.

05/18/2023 - Don
Awesome pizza

09/26/2020 - MenuPix User
Very good taste

07/26/2020 - Greg
The best pizza around southern Wis hands down!

07/28/2018 - Emily M.
Family owned and operated. Amazing pizza.

04/14/2018 - LaVerna Roningen
Please update your prices so we know more when we order next time. You have the best pizzas ever!!!

06/17/2017 - Duane Fay
My wife and I just moved to the neighborhood and are looking for a good pizza place. this is not it. we came in and ordered a 12" pizza with sausage, mushroom, spinach (theirs is from a can) and 1/2 anchovie. after half an hour they brought out our pizza as ordered but with pepperoni added. I dislike pepperoni and my wife hates it. Their remedy was to offer us a smaller pizza made to our original specs. When we decided not to wait another half hour the waitress gave us a whopping $4 off our bill. My wife didn't eat the pizza but did cook a frozen pizza when we got home. I can not in good conscience recommend this as a good place to eat

07/07/2016 - Gordon & Penny
Best restaurant in town. Love the pizza cheese bread and the calzones. Great staff

07/04/2016 - Greg & Joanne Becker
Best pizza in town❣ Family owned.... Great staff. We love it there.

07/02/2016 - AP
Best Authentic Pizzas in town. Always very friendly and nice staffs!!!!!