Reviews for Pennelopy's Pizzaria

03/14/2014 - Kevin
For the 3rd time now in 2 months I have stopped in on varying days of the week. Today my family stopped to have the buffet. 10 minutes and no one realizes that we are even in the building on a Friday at 4 P.M. Took a look at what was on the buffet and the pizzas looked as if they had been sitting for at least an hour or more. Stir the gravy for mashed potatoes and the film that formed over it was at least an 1/8 thick. Stir it and the film does not go away. Never returning their again. Food quality and customer service are non-existant.

03/19/2013 - Erica M.
My husband and I have been saying for years we need to try this place every time we pass by and tonight we finally did. The service was great, our waitress was so friendly and very attentive. The food was also very good, even considering it was not during prime hours when we went. Some buffets are dissapointing if you so not get there during lunch or dinner. The salad was delicious, the chicken was warm and moist, and the pizza taste and selection was good as well. We will definately go again!