Reviews for Thirsty Pagan Brewing

05/29/2025 - Lyndsay R.
The pizza here is some of the best around, with a perfect crust that's not too deep but still hearty, and the toppings are always flavorful and fresh. The atmosphere is welcoming with live music on occasion, friendly staff, and a nice dog-friendly outdoor seating area that makes it a great place to relax and enjoy a cold beer alongside delicious food.

11/07/2021 - MenuPix User
First time to the brewery, spent over $80 including a large pizza for that evening. Unaware of thier policies, which were not explained to us, the pizza had the stems of the peppers on the pizza. I called the next day to speak to manager and she hung up on me. I called back and never received an apology for her hanging up on me. She went on to explain the $30 pizza was shown to us by the server before paying for it. They didn't tell us that if we had a complaint we should make it then. We didn't see the stems till we got back to the place we were staying for the weekend.

I don't recommend the food, it's over priced and not very good and not made well. The management has MUCH to be desired.
The beer wasn't great either.