Reviews for Sheila's Pizza

03/16/2025 - Kimberly R.
The food is consistently delicious, especially the chicken wings and thin-crust pizza, which hold up well even when eaten cold. The staff is friendly and attentive, making it a solid choice for carry-out, though the pizza can be quite greasy for some preferences.

01/23/2024 - T. Todd
Great food, fast delivery, friendly service!!!

10/03/2023 - Carbofed
Terrific good, great delivery

07/16/2023 - Terry
I love their pizza, and salads and sandwiches. Love Rita!

05/31/2023 - Cheryl D
Prices are way off. They are much higher!!!

05/07/2021 - MenuPix User
Owner is very rude and unprofessional
Food taste like cardboard and I had mold on my sandwich
I do not recommend this place
Bugs in the pizza box when food is delivered to your home

The owner ( Rita) is pure evil
She takes in foster children for the money and neglects and abuses them while in her care!!!!

04/17/2021 - MenuPix User
I have never had a more horrible experience. The pizza was cold and very poorly made. The lady who introduced herself as "i run this place" was rude and obnoxious. I will not ever return. Ive had better pizza from walmarts freezer o only gave 1 star becaise there wasnt an option for none.

05/31/2019 - MenuPix User
Been eating pizza from here since I was a kid. One of my favorite pizza places.

08/22/2018 - Stephanie R.
This is my favorite pizza place anywhere around Deatsville.

04/04/2017 - Kristy
After waiting on hold for 4 mins I called back and ordered off their online menu....I was told I don't get a second pizza for $10.....when it clearly says I can on the menu. So I couldn't order a second for that price, I was told its not available! !!!

01/20/2011 - Amanda's favorite customers
The cashiers are friendly and always know what we want. The pizza is great!