Reviews for Upper Crust Pizza Co

04/28/2024 - Will W.
Awesome food and service

01/29/2024 - MenuPix User
The waitress Yanira ruined my dinner. My two friends and I had just finished a day of snowboarding at Mammoth and were looking for a good place to eat. After telling Yanira I had a dairy allergy she became very short and rude with me. I wanted to order a sandwich and asked if there were any sauces that came on the sandwich. Yanira said that there wasn’t. On the menu it says it comes with spicy mustard, pastrami and pickles (all ok for me), but to cover my bases I asked the question above and trusted her help me with my order. Big mistake. The sandwich came slathered in mayo. I also have an egg allergy that she did not give me enough time to tell her about, and I felt that I was being judged after telling her my first allergy. I let Yanira know I could not eat the sandwich and she aggressively took the plate from in front of me and sent it back to the kitchen. I was going to tell her that I would order something else so that they didn’t have to remake it, but Yanira did not give me the chance. She took the sandwich and didn’t look or speak to me. I tried to let her know that I didn’t want it anymore and she said, “ It’s too late the kitchen is already remaking it.” Then she rushed off. For the rest of the night she would be very nice to my friends at the table and would not look, face or talk to me. I asked to speak with her before I paid the bill. I apologized to her, and asked if I upset her or miscommunicated with her in anyway. To which she replied “What, you want me to apologize?”. We exchanged a few more polite words but I finally realized that there was no getting through to her. I paid for my sandwich that I didn’t want and left. She made me look like a fool in front of my friends I was dining with, judged me for the allergies I was born with and was outright rude for my entire meal. The food on the other hand contrary to Yanira’s embarrassment for waitressing was very good. The wings are some of the best I’ve ever had. I apologize to everyone else at the restaurant, they were all lovely.

01/04/2021 - Ann
Great pizza. We order regularly. Love the crust. Sauce is god too.

09/17/2020 - Michael
Out of town visitor... got the reg crust "pearl" pizza. It's a garlic chicken pizza. This is the best pizza I've ever had.