Reviews for New York Pizza

07/01/2025 - Devon R.
The pizza here has consistently impressed me with its great taste, perfect crust, and balanced sauce, all at a reasonable price. When I needed a large order for a work event, the staff was friendly and accommodating, delivering everything hot and on time. Whether grabbing a quick slice or ordering for a group, the quality and service never disappoint, making it a favorite choice for New York style pizza.

09/17/2024 - Heather H.
We had a great experience with the service, price, and taste of the pizza we ordered for a New Year's Eve gathering at our house. The kids enjoyed the pizza, and we were pleased with the value and efficiency of the service. It's become one of our favorite spots for pizza, with consistent quality and friendly service.

02/28/2022 - Hanna
I love this place . The best pizza i ever had in Elk-grove. I ordered lunch special L one topping only 10.99 . Staff members are always friendly.

02/28/2022 - Hanna
I love this place . The best pizza i ever had in Elk-grove. I ordered lunch special L one topping only 10.99 . Staff members are always friendly.

02/22/2022 - Crystal
The best pizza I ever had in Elk -Grove. I love the service at this place. Highly recommended this place

09/05/2009 - Carol DeWeerdt
Oh my Gosh!!!!
I went to this place to buy pizza for my sons birthday, I ordered a medium specialty pizza (Bbq chicken) and a medium 3 topping I used a buy 1 get one free coupon and that may have been my mistake, but I paid 18.23 for this pizza and it was seriously only slightly larger (1 pc maybe) than a pizza hut personal...I took it up and asked if they make the right size and the employee said yea you used a coupon....I said so 2 of these little pizzas would have been 36 bucks????? HELLO!!!! so I left with my little pizzas and figured well I guess everyone can have a slice with chips... (must be excellent pizza for that kind of money) WRONG it was dough with some crappy bbq sauce and a few pieces of chicken 6 bell pepper pieces (yes I counted!!) and a tiny, tiny bit of mixed cheese. The thing tasted just short of bad and what a joke for 18 bucks I will never never never go there again and I will be sure to tell everyone I can think of to spread the word New York Pizza is a rip off!!!!