Reviews for Anthony's Pizza & Pasta

07/08/2025 - Ashley M.
Growing up on the East Coast, I found their large extra cheese pizza surprisingly close to the authentic New York and New Jersey style I miss, with perfectly cooked crusts and fresh ingredients that hit the spot. While the chicken parmesan and salad were delicious and the gluten-free dough was impressively soft, the cheesecake fell flat for me, and the cost means we can only enjoy it occasionally.

09/09/2024 - Chet T.
I deducted one star from my rating due to the pricing, as it can be a bit steep for regular visits. Growing up on the east coast, the pizza here is the closest I've found to the flavors of New York and New Jersey. Despite the cost, the large pie with extra cheese is worth indulging in occasionally for a taste of home. The service and food quality are usually satisfactory, although there was a slight hiccup during my last visit when the garlic bread was forgotten and had to be requested multiple times.

01/31/2020 - Sherry
We ordered (to go) a few of their pasta dishes and a salad. The food was Great. Getting ready to order some more to go and 2 extra. I'm having surgery and I want some extra food in the freezer. The price was very reasonable for the quality and taste of the food. Thank you Anthonys for coming to Brighton.

01/11/2015 - Corrine
Best pizza this side of town!!!!

12/16/2014 - Mark
Well, I can't give you a review of how the food is, because their menu isn't a menu at all. It's just a vague rundown of what types of food they have, but not anything specific. Frustrated, at the joke, they call a menu, I decided to click on the "Order Now" button, foolishly thinking I would finally see what they have, how much it costs, and go ahead and order something, "Quick" and "Easy", like it says....Wrong again. It's not quick, and it's not easy. In fact, it's completely impossible. After picking a location, then the next step was picking the date that I would like to pick up my order, because apparently New Yorkers need a ctalendar because they must plan ahead and order what they are going to want to eat later in the week. Or, their website is such a joke that by the time you navigate it, it'll be the next day when you actually get to eat. Doesn't mater though. After I picked todays date, it was time to choose a time to pick it up....Surprise!! it won't let you pick a time, and therefore, won't let you click on the "continue" button, so I still can't see what's on the menu. Now that the website wasted a half hour of my life, I'll be damned if I'm going to call now, and expect them to tell me all of my meal choices, and prices before I die of starvation... Can anyone tell me how many days are in a New York minute?