Reviews for Ernie's Pizzeria

06/22/2025 - Kenneth H.
Ernie's pizza has been a favorite of mine since childhood, offering a delicious crust and fresh, perfectly balanced sauce that keeps me coming back. The friendly service and authentic atmosphere make it a welcoming experience, and the tomato pie stands out as a true highlight every time.

03/18/2025 - Michelle I.
I've been enjoying Ernie's since I was five, and it continues to impress me with its delicious pizza. The atmosphere is relaxed, and the service is friendly, making it a solid choice for a satisfying meal.

05/07/2024 - Don R.
great food

07/07/2023 - MenuPix User
Sensational

05/07/2023 - Gail
My absolute favorite pizza! Pat and the staff are top notch!!

10/30/2021 - MenuPix User
Best pizza my family ever had.

06/24/2021 - John C
My fav in New Haven since I first went there in 1978....Pat nails it every time..perfect,crisp crust..great people with a great history of doing it right !!

04/28/2021 - Bill
Tomato pies as can only be made in New Haven with grated cheese. The rest of the world does not know that Apizza is a tomato pie not a cheese pie. Ernie's is one of the best.

03/26/2021 - John and Kathyclead
we go every Friday it is the best pizza anywhere in Connecticut ,better than Wooster st. and the resturant is supper

09/05/2020 - MenuPix User
Excellent every visit

02/18/2015 - Linda Michaud
My favorite Pizza in all of CT . Always the same ,not like some of the rest some of the others , that are so burn't you can' t eat them. We tried them all in new haven and near by , and Erine's is our favorite. Linda M.