Reviews for Athens Gyros

06/17/2025 - Ale H.
The wings here are seriously some of the best around, especially with that tangy BBQ sauce and the apple-celery slaw on the side. The vibe inside is way more spacious and chill than you'd expect from the outside, plus the bar is well-stocked with craft beers and great cocktails like their Manhattans. Ordering at the counter is quick and easy, service is friendly, and there's even a drive-thru or curbside pickup if you're in a hurry.

02/03/2025 - Robert Y.
These wings are some of the best I've had in the Madison area, especially with that tangy BBQ sauce that hits just right. The atmosphere is surprisingly spacious, and the staff is always friendly and quick with service. Plus, the menu has a mix of options that keeps things interesting, from gyros to tacos, and I can't wait to go back for more!

01/10/2021 - Very rude customer service
We stopped there to get food for myself, my husband and our daughter on the way home from work a few days ago. We got 3 burgers, one fry, one lemonade and 2 slices of pie. It cost about $50! What really irked me was that my lemonade was fully packed with ice and barely had any lemonade in there. I don't think that you could have gotten one more ice cube in it! I mentioned this to the lady who worked in drive thru and she told me that she couldn't take out any ice and and even if she did that she couldn't put me any more lemonade because they were supposed to put a full scoop in there. I have ordered a lemonade from them many times and it was never that full!. She was quite rude and I find it to be very cheap of them (especially after spending $50) to be this way about it!