Reviews for Number 1 Brothers Pizza

01/17/2021 - MenuPix User
Pizza was terrible. I went because all the good reviews that I saw. I got 2 medium pizzas and fried zucchini $49 nobody ate it.

12/25/2017 - James Martin
We have recently moved to Avondale. We use to eat at Rays pizza and we loved their pizza. We went to #1 Brothers Pizza our first week after we moved in. WOW.. Best pizza ever. Great customer service. We eat their every week. Thanks #1 Brothers Pizza for excellent food.

10/04/2011 - thisPIZZASUCKS
The WORST restaurant ever. this place is a joke. Went in to have lunch with my lady. the soda was flat. the wings were over cooked to the point of not even being edible. they tasted old,like they had been leftovers from the night before and had the consistency of beef jerky.I have never passed up eating hot wings. im no gordon ramsey by any means. This was insanely awful.unprecedented.

They messed up on my lady's calzone and had to re cook it. they dont serve celery with there wings so i ran up to the store to grab some. got back and discovered how "great" the wings were,my lady's couldnt eat her calzone,it was just a greasy mess. spent a total of 40 for lunch at this god damn place so i i was pretty pissed. got a to-go-container and gave it to the girl at the register and said "tell that guy to eat this garbage"(pointing at the cook joe)

They did not have ANYONE who spoke English that was in any managment position that i could talk to in order to complain(at any of their locations).I finally get ahold of AJ in avondale who tells me"joe has been in the business for 13 years,he's a good cook" and that " i can get the same order again". so i try called in to the suprise location to recieve my comp'd order. instead of getting 2 calzones i just asked to have one large pizza instead(which is cheaper according to the menu)and i start getting insulted by Mira, ,who is easily the most incompetent person ever in life. she starts saying" i probably dont work and sit at home all day trying to get free stuff". I explain to her that her company is garbage and food sucks and she is worthless.

decide i have had enough, call Aj back and tell him what she said to which he replies"you wanted 2 x-large pizzas?? thats not what we agreed upon,you get 2 calzones and thats it" . i explain i dont want anything and tell him how atrocious Mira is at the suprise location,then AJ says" she's the sweetest person ever she wouldnt do that,she's been in the business for 13 years" .implying that i just made it up and somehow 13 years justifies anything whatsoever.

i tell him i would rather a refund because im not gonna eat food with spit on it thats the same crappy food as last time. he acted like he couldnt care any less at this point. i finally tell him "you know what? lets go ahead and get that deal called into the peoria location" to which i plan on taking each piece of comp'd food and throwing it away right in front of them,then explaining what i think of they're company during the process.

#1 brothers is a disgrace, terrible food, terrible people

#1 in garbage

10/02/2009 - PIZZALOVER
tHE BESTT PIZZA IN AZZ!! IT IS ABSOULUTELY AMAZINGGG!!! EVERYTHING IS SO GOOOD ND THEY HAVE SO MUCH TO CHOOSE FROM! KIDS LOVEE ITT AND ITS NOT EXPENSIVE IN THIS ECONOMY ALSO WORKERS ARE VERY FRIENDLY. YOU HAVE TO TRY IT .. WONT BE DISSAPOINTED!!!

01/08/2009 - pladletuce
Fantastic NY style pizza. These guys are all from Brooklyn, so they know what NY pizza is supposed to taste like...good prices too!