Reviews for Cary's Pizza

06/09/2025 - Douglas O.
The crust was airy with a wonderful flavor, perfectly complementing the fresh toppings and tasty sauce on each pizza we devoured. The friendly, accommodating staff and the cozy, charming atmosphere made the whole experience even more enjoyable, leaving me eager for my next visit.

05/29/2024 - Janay P.
I love this place!

06/09/2022 - MenuPix User
One of the best Hawaiian pizzas I've ever had! Perfectly balanced and layered with flavor!

04/06/2022 - MenuPix User
Best Pizza Ever!!!!!!

12/16/2021 - Jack
Cary has ran his pizzeria here for many years. Consistently making great food. I love his pizzas especially the chicken cacciatora pizza and the tomato garlic supreme. Awesome.

11/11/2021 - Paulette Hayden
Love Cary's 🍕🍕🍕. The Pizza is not only great, prices reasonable, and friendly personality....but he is also the only one who never gets lost delivering to us!! Might not mean a lot to some people, but sure does to me. Thanks Cary!!!

10/19/2021 - Rosemary
Totally awesome 🥰

09/10/2021 - Kim
it was fantastic, waitress was great and food arrived hot and delicious, would definately eat there again

10/30/2020 - Tom
Best pizza place in town. The wings and pizza are wonderful plus the staff are so nice. Take out or eat in highly recommended

02/28/2018 - Phil
staff is very friendly and helpful, BUT, if you're looking for a pizza with "mega meat" and "extra cheese" or extra anything, this is not the right place to go. I'd head to pizza hut or the frozen pizza aisle of the store. it just does not measure up here, only best part of the pizza was the crust.

02/24/2017 - don
Cary's Pizza came highly recommend and we tried it first time last evening. GREAT pizza. We'll be back.

We ordered the organic whole wheat veggie pizza with extra tomato for take-out and it was delicious. The whole wheat crust is well worth the extra money. The staff is friendly and efficient. The restaurant is small and unassuming but let looks deter you from trying the best pizza in town.