Reviews for New Bethel Ordinary

08/01/2025 - Lisa B.
I've enjoyed the pizza here twice, appreciating the generous toppings and balanced sauce, though it may not suit those who prefer heavy sauce. Despite a busy evening, the service was prompt, with our order ready well before the estimated time, and the staff remained friendly and attentive throughout our visit. The menu offers a variety of well-prepared options beyond pizza, such as wings with flavorful sauces and tasty appetizers, making it a reliable choice for a satisfying meal.

08/09/2024 - Bruce
Best pizza I've had since moving to Indy in 1985.
When my Dentist found out I had moved to Wanamaker, she told me about this great pizza place she grew up going to and recommended New Bethel Ordinary.
Now when my best friend visits from out of town, we always go here for Pizza!

11/17/2023 - Joe
Good food and great place to gather.

07/21/2021 - Niemann
Always so damn good. We live about 15 mins away and always get it to go...even after it gets here...still hot and weighs about 10#'s plus! So yummy!!!!