Reviews for Casey Key Fish House

05/12/2024 - Ginny N.
i love it

09/03/2022 - JChaney
Absolutely the best food in town. Friendly staff and great view. It's our go to place.

07/08/2022 - MenuPix User
Amazing Food!! Everything we tried was EXCELLENT!! Best crab cakes I've ever had! Stuffed shrimp and yellow tail fish were cooked to perfection and the key lime pie was amazing! Look no further this is the BEST seafood in Sarasota

12/25/2020 - VW
None of staff wearing masks, very thoughtless p, esp for older patrons and staff.

05/19/2010 - James Spackle
Too many better seafood places around here. Appetizers appeared to be from Sam's Club(out of a frozen bag.

04/06/2010 - Hungry in Sarasota
Had a terrible restaurant experience at this restaurant. We placed our name on the list and were told that the wait would be 45 minutes. We waited for an hour and twenty minutes. When our name was finally called, another party took our table. When we complained the hostess, she promised us another table and took us to the table in the restaurant where we waited for that party to settle their check. When they left, the table was removed while we stood and watched. We walked out of the restaurant. May have great food, we will never know. The service was awful.