Reviews for Herbie's Restaurant

05/26/2025 - Selene D.
The fried Mahi had the perfect breading, and every BBQ sauce in the bucket was incredible-I especially loved the clam chowder and fish dip, which were bursting with flavor. The short rib poutine and pork belly burnt ends stood out with their unique, rich tastes, while the chicken and smashed potatoes became my favorite entree thanks to the perfectly cooked chicken and amazing sauce. The staff was friendly and attentive, our food arrived quickly, and the lively atmosphere made the whole experience truly enjoyable.

06/01/2024 - Krishna R.
great service and excellent food.

06/23/2015 - Norman
Had awesome smoked fish dip. Its wahoo and mahi and smoked right there. The food had a fantastic combination of flavors. Key lime pie was best ever had. Very pleased,

05/15/2015 - Harry
We have been coming to the Keys for 30 year We have ate regularly at the old Herbie's We just ate at the Newly opened Herbie's one of the WORST meals we have in the Keys They say the Seafood is fresh, we had the Dolphin, it was frozen, it might have been local but it was not fresh. The French Fries were soggy, the tomatoes & lettuce was old & warm. Will not ever eat there again & will not recommend Herbie's to any one