Reviews for Deer Park Tavern

07/04/2025 - Amanda P.
The Philly cheese steak dip, chili, and drinks were delicious, the service was impeccable with our server Aaron perfect for our group of 10, the food was traditional bar fare with highlights like loaded nachos and beef stew earning a 10/10, the atmosphere was casual and kid-friendly with a nice outdoor area, drinks were good and reasonably priced with strong cocktails and great Bloody Marys, and despite an off-putting smell upon arrival and some parking challenges, the overall experience was enjoyable enough that my family and I plan to return soon.

06/28/2024 - Ma A.
The Philly cheese steak dip, chili, and drinks at this restaurant were absolutely delicious. Despite an off-putting smell upon arrival, the impeccable service made up for it. The bar food was great, the drinks were tasty, and the overall experience was enjoyable - I would definitely consider returning.

10/16/2009 - Stacey
First, keep in mind that I'm married to an accountant and we always look for the most bang for the buck. I think this place has okay food. Some entrees better than others. It's just a bit overpriced for what you're getting. There was a good deal they used to have on veggie burgers with fries (2 burgers for 8.95) that is STILL advertised on their site but is no longer the case. I haven't seen a local burger worth 8-10 bucks when it's just one burger-and it's a veggie burger nonetheless! On a very recent order there, I paid more for less than what I used to get with the two veggie burgers and fries there. Unless you're going out for a night on the town, or you want to drink more than eat, save your money and go to Newark Deli and Bagels instead. Tastes better, the burger is just as big, and at this point it's cheaper even if the fries are ordered separately.