Reviews for Miltonian Pizzeria & Wing House

03/08/2024 - MenuPix User

01/27/2024 - MenuPix User

01/16/2024 - MenuPix User

01/07/2024 - MenuPix User

11/13/2023 - MenuPix User

11/09/2023 - MenuPix User

11/07/2023 - MenuPix User

10/30/2023 - MenuPix User

10/30/2023 - MenuPix User

10/27/2023 - MenuPix User

06/06/2023 - Calems
Pasta dishes and pizza are superb! Excellent gravy. Consistently good. Been patronizing for nearly 13 years!

03/03/2023 - George Herrmann
We think this restaurant serves the best pizza in the area from Lewes down to Dewey beach.
The atmosphere is friendly, families are welcome and both booths and tables are available.
The house salad dressing is tasty and we wonder how it is made. Parking is not a problem,
service is prompt.

09/07/2021 - MenuPix User
It's an ok place to dine at if you don't mind hearing the manager screaming at the staff the whole time. Jesus.

01/18/2021 - MenuPix User
Got spaghetti with meat sauce take out. Not enough meat sauce. Would have been better with less spaghetti and more sauce. It was stirred up. Better if sauce was left poured on top. Have had this in the restaurant and it was excellent. This take out order was awful.

09/13/2020 - MenuPix User
This menupix menu attached to their website is very old, no veal part anymore.etc. The owners should update as changes occur.

08/05/2020 - Cheryl W
Love their wings and kamikazi sauce. Pizza is delicious and prices are reasonable.

04/25/2020 - MenuPix User
Very distressing to see the food preparation people and servers operating without gloves or masks during this pandemic

01/08/2020 - Patron
I ordered carryout. While waiting for my order management harshly/loudly reprimanded the staff/trainee who were taking orders over the phone and entering them into the system. Unacceptable. Patrons don't want to see/hear staff humiliated in this fashion. Some management training classes are sorely needed.

11/24/2019 - MenuPix User
Delicious and friendly service

08/23/2019 - MenuPix User
Very disappointed in the pizza just a few days ago, August 22, 2019. We have been getting the pizza there for quite a few years, always consistent, great crust with a lot of sauce, but found the other night pizza was overcooked, not enough sauce and bland. Just saying!!!!

08/15/2019 - MenuPix User
Great service , Awesome food ! I drive all the way from Bethany Beach to get the veggie pizza .
Strombolis are incredible . Loaded with veggies , super portions . Love this place !

12/30/2018 - MenuPix User
Tried everything from the pizza, subs, pasta, extremely disappointed ..multiple times. The only reason for two stars is the crab wings.

06/22/2018 - MenuPix User
It always looks clean when I go there and I never witnessed any of that dirty stuff people are talking about! The food is not the greatest but lets face it this is not South Philly!

05/31/2018 - Marion
Good pizza.

06/13/2017 - Keith
Best sausage and onion pizza around

12/16/2016 - Tony
Disgusting. This used to be a good restaurant. It is no longer. We ordered a cheesesteak. There was no cheese to speak of. The pizza had the thinnest, burnt layer of cheese i have ever seen. And what self-respecting restaurant serves packet dressing with their salads? I will never order from here again. I actually threw my food in the trash because i couldnt eat it.

And to the locals who rave about this place, im not a disgruntled ex employee. Im a disappointed customer who will never eat here again.

07/18/2013 - GW Tall Yella House at Love Creek
THEEEEE BEST PIZZA EVER NO FRKN LIE .. WHOEVER WROTE THAT NEGATIVE REVIEW IS JUST A DISGRUNTLED EMPLOYEE SHAME ON YA!

10/01/2011 - MaryC
This is very important information for everyone that eats here or plans to ever eat here. DON'T!
This is one of the most unsanitary places that are allowed to sell food. No one that prepares food at this place ever washes their hands, they only have 1 tiny box of gloves for the employees that is actually hidden and taken out when getting visited by health and sanitation check ups. All the dishes, glasses and silverware are hardly washed and touched by practically every employee. I have actually witnessed the kitchen staff sneeze on the food, wipe their sweat and noses with their hands and then prepare your sandwiches and subs, i have seen the person that prepares the soups try the soup and then spit it back in, i have seen the waitresses touch the salads with their unwashed hands when preparing it, i have seen them use rotting vegetables, and lettuces with live worms and slugs.
Also they treat their employees horribly, curse, smoke in the kitchen with them, sexually harass, hide their credit card tips, cut their paychecks. And to whoever works for the job departments, not one of their employees is on the books, they refuse to pay taxes for any of them and only pay them $2 an hour!!
I CAN'T BELIEVE THIS PLACE HASN'T BEEN SHUT DOWN!

02/21/2010 - Mary
The best pizza in Sussex County! A pleasant, clean, and well-managed restaurant. When greek specialties are available, spanakopita and moussaka in particular, you are in for a real treat!

02/17/2010 - not telling
the best pizza in milton

01/04/2010 - Mark
Hands down the best pizza in the region. My favorite is the bodacious buffalo chicken pizza but all of them are fantastic. Great wings and Italian dinners too.

08/22/2008 - Leanne
Great wings and pizza. My new favorite by far.