Pettinari's Deli & Pizza

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

918 Roosevelt Hwy
Hilton, NY 14468

Phone: (585) 392-4450

Website

Neighborhood: Hilton

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Sheet Regular Pizza $20.95
• A generous sheet of pizza, ample enough to cater to a crowd. Be it smothered with traditional tangy sauce and mozzarella, adorned with fragrant garlic, seasoned with robust Abruzzese herbs, or drizzled with creamy white sauce, it's bound to bring joy to the table.
• Sheet Specialty Pizza $26.95
• Specialty pizza options include Steak, Sweet & Sour Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, Breakfast, and Reuben.
• Large 16" Specialty Pizza $16.95
• Large 16 pizza with choices of steak, sweet & sour chicken, breakfast, Reuben, or buffalo chicken.
• Large 16" Regular Pizza $13.95
• Enjoy a large 16-inch Regular Pizza with your choice of preparation: White, Garlic, Abruzzese or Traditional.
• Medium 14" Specialty Pizza $13.95
• A 14-inch, medium-sized pizza that features choice of buffalo chicken, steak, Reuben, sweet and sour chicken, or breakfast toppings.

Hours

Sorry, we don't have hours for this restaurant yet. We'll be updating the hours for this restaurant soon.

Monday: Add Hours
Tuesday:
Wednesday:
Thursday:
Friday:
Saturday:
Sunday:

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Pettinari's Deli & Pizza

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Pettinari's Deli & Pizza

Write a Review

  4.2 stars - Based on 37 reviews

#9 out of 28 restaurants in Hilton

#1 of 1 Deli in Hilton

5 star				18 reviews	49%
4 star				16 reviews	43%
3 star				0 reviews	0%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				3 reviews	8%

Top Reviews of Pettinari's Deli & Pizza

04/15/2025 - Lupita A.
This deli is a treasure trove of deliciousness, featuring homemade sausages that are to die for and a fantastic selection of fresh meats that make every meal a winner. Plus, with the sweetest chihuahua roaming around and a staff that treats you like family, I can't help but stop by weekly for my grocery fix!

06/16/2024 - Herman P.
Always good.

05/19/2021 - BELAIR
THEY ARE GETTING WOSE

07/26/2019 - Ed
Have been going there for years my go to place when throwing a big party pizza done on time and hot

05/20/2018 - Neil Belair
Been in Hilton since 1965---Been in Petts a million times--- TODAY
Had the worst sub of my life (5/20/18/) Ordered Italian Asstr'd----Got a huge loaf of bread ( sliced 1/4" thick on one side and 2" on the
other with 1 (ONE) piece of meat, a little tomatoe, a little red pepper, tiny piece of red onion
AND no more---
After all these years, you are history-----Neil Belair, 392-2290

08/27/2014 - N.Belair
Had to re-write--2nd sub was super-not sure what happened to the previous one--Belair

08/26/2014 - N. Belair
Been going to "PETTS" for years , been in Hilton since 1965
Todays SUBS were awful==very little meat, more bread than anything---They have gone downhill---They need to go to La Belllas and learn how to make a real sub---Unless they greatly improve, we are thru with Petts.---Belair, Hilton, NY