Hours
Open Today:
11:00am-11:00pm
Monday11:00am
-11:00pm
Tuesday11:00am
-11:00pm
Wednesday11:00am
-11:00pm
Thursday11:00am
-11:00pm
Friday11:00am
-11:00pm
Saturday11:00am
-11:00pm
Sunday12:00pm
-10:00pm
View the Menu
View Menus
Restaurant Details
Delivery
Yes
Payment
Accepts Credit Cards
Parking
Good for Kids
Attire
Casual
Alcohol
Reservations
Cuisines:
Pizza,
Subs,
Sandwiches
Price Point
$
$ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
WiFi
No
Outdoor Seats
Restaurant Description
Is this your restaurant?
Click to add your description here.
Restaurant Photos
View Menu
See Menus
Write a Review for Calogero's Pizza
Reviews for Calogero's Pizza
#28 out of 32 restaurants in Old Forge
#7 of 7 Pizza in Old Forge
Top Reviews of Calogero's Pizza
04/16/2024 - MenuPix User
04/10/2024 - MenuPix User
02/09/2024 - MenuPix User
12/07/2023 - MenuPix User
09/27/2023 - Sherri Rook
Absolutely delicious!!
08/11/2023 - MenuPix User
The best pizza in the world!!!!
04/08/2023 - Pat Valunas
Yesterday was my first time ordering your pizza. I am thrilled I did. It's the best pizza in Old Forge!!! Crust is like the old Gabello's or Ghigerelli's but better. Sauce is delicious, cheese freshly grated. EXCELLENT!!!
03/31/2023 - MenuPix User
My my absolute new favorite pizza in Old Forge or anywhere!❤️❤️❤️
01/20/2023 - Evelyn
Best pizza in Old Forge!
05/06/2022 - MenuPix User
A great, light, crispy (not burnt crust). Perfect balance of cheese and sauce. For a small take out only pizza place, it tops several pizza joints along the main street of the "pizza capital" of the world. I ALWAYS thought Old Forge pizza was over-rated, and most of it is.... Except this place and dominos
04/05/2022 - Patti Bartuska
The most delicious pizza I ever had!
04/01/2022 - J Sibley
Great Pizza… Just don’t call on Friday super busy.
02/19/2022 - Allan conte hbg pa
Unteal.pizza. wish it was closer. Alwsys get 2 to 3 psr bakes for others in harrisburg. Try it you will never go elsewhere
02/09/2022 - Paula
Best pizza in town!
02/19/2021 - Anita
Pizza is awesome. Nice and crispy. You can have it onion or no onion. Will differently go back again.
02/19/2021 - MenuPix User
Had 6 cuts of pizza out first try. Outstanding!!! Can not wait to go back for much more. It was just heavenly!!!!
01/12/2021 - MenuPix User
Ordered it last Friday. It is delicious! Crust is crispy, a little sweetness to the sauce and the cheese is perfect.
10/30/2020 - Jan Nappi
Crisp (not chewy!) crust, fresh tasting tomato, subtle thin onion pieces. The cheese is perfect.
09/10/2020 - Ashlee
Best pizza ever! Get it and you will have the number on speed dial for sure!!!!!
06/13/2020 - jack
crust crisp, tomatoes COOKED , not just heated,l Like Old Forge pizza of years ago. Tomatoes are cooked not just heated as the cheese melts, Dough crisp, not soft like bread. Good service.