Geno Nottolini's Pizza

Popular Menu Items

• Basic Cheese 16" Large $20.99
• Basic Cheese $12.49
• Over an inch thick pizza with a heavy bread crust covered with extra sauce lots of cheese and all the fresh ingredients you want.
• Chicken Wings (6) $7.99
• Choice of sauce or plain
• Cannoli $3.49
• Every Day Special $21.99
• 2 medium thin crust pizzas with 1 topping each.

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

933 Indiana Ave
Sheboygan, WI 53081

Phone: (920) 458-4505

Website

Neighborhood: Sheboygan

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Geno Nottolini's Pizza

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Geno Nottolini's Pizza

Write a Review

  3.6 stars - Based on 14 reviews

#48 out of 210 restaurants in Sheboygan

#6 of 21 Pizza in Sheboygan

5 star				3 reviews	21%
4 star				4 reviews	29%
3 star				6 reviews	43%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				1 reviews	7%

Top Reviews of Geno Nottolini's Pizza

03/08/2025 - Gerard A.
The pizza I enjoyed exceeded my expectations, especially considering the exceptional service and reasonable prices. After just one visit, I became a regular customer, returning multiple times for the delicious pizza and perfectly crafted drinks.

07/24/2014 - never eat here
Food is very inconsistent. Thay don't have good quality control over the food. I was served Alfredo that tasted sour. Service sucks too. I waited 20 min to get my order taken and we was the only ones there. Then I waited over 45 min to get our food. If it takes this long I would expect the food to be fresh and good.

02/19/2014 - Denise
Restaurant on Indiana Ave,Sheboygan, is very nice, very good food and a good variety. Something for everyone, pizza,pasta, chicken, sandwiches, hot dogs and even cookies.