Mayflower Seafood Restaurant

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

1729 Highway 19 E # 1
Elizabethton, TN 37643

Phone: (423) 542-3667

Website

Neighborhood: Elizabethton

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Fried Chicken Tenders
• 24 pieces. Feeds 6 people.
• Fried White Fish
• 12 pieces. Feeds 6 people.
• Fried Popcorn Shrimp
• 3 pounds. Feeds 6 people.
• Fried Baby Flounder
• 24 pieces. Feeds 6 people.
• Chicken Wings
• 30 wings.

Hours

Sorry, we don't have hours for this restaurant yet. We'll be updating the hours for this restaurant soon.

Monday: Add Hours
Tuesday:
Wednesday:
Thursday:
Friday:
Saturday:
Sunday:

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Mayflower Seafood Restaurant

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Mayflower Seafood Restaurant

Write a Review

  4.0 stars - Based on 86 reviews

#53 out of 73 restaurants in Elizabethton

#2 of 3 Seafood in Elizabethton

5 star				33 reviews	38%
4 star				30 reviews	35%
3 star				17 reviews	20%
2 star				3 reviews	3%
1 star				3 reviews	3%

Top Reviews of Mayflower Seafood Restaurant

07/16/2025 - Joshua M.
The seafood here comes in generous portions, bursting with fresh flavors and served at reasonable prices that make each meal feel like a great value. The staff is friendly and attentive, providing timely service that adds to the enjoyable dining experience, even if the decor leans toward a nostalgic, retro vibe. While some sides like hush puppies and baked potatoes could be improved in freshness, the overall quality and variety of dishes ensure that there's something delicious for everyone, making it a place I look forward to returning to.

06/22/2025 - Gary M
I was at the Mayflower today for Lunch with my wife and son. I ordered Scallops and Clam strips deep fried. My wife ordered shrimp broiled. Son ordered shrimp and oysters broiled. We have been going there for over 4 years and never had meals like this before! My scallops were dry, the clam strips, half were over cooked. My wife and sons meals were very small more like an entry. Both were over done. Granted, the prices aren't bad but the consistency has gone way down considerably and the amount you get are no where you used to get! I don't know if we'll be back in the future or not! We'll be looking for a new seafood restaurant!

05/22/2024 - Madisyn G.
Tasty

05/18/2024 - Dana W.
The seafood dishes at this restaurant are reasonably priced and generously portioned, perfect for a satisfying meal. The service is friendly and efficient, making for an enjoyable dining experience overall.

10/29/2023 - Marsha
Wonderful food

06/18/2023 - MenuPix User
Pitiful...can't even seat people correctly...hostess is a joke.

04/29/2023 - Darrell Gillespie
I drove from Greeneville,Tn which is about an hour drive one way to get food from the Mayflower. The food is amazing always fresh and cooked to perfection. My hat off to the cook last and management for an awesome job. The trip tonElizbethon is well worth it!!!!

03/10/2022 - Evelyn H.
I've had takeout from here a few times and eaten in once. Food has been excellent and you definitely get your money's worth!

11/24/2021 - MenuPix User
We are from Pa. One of the best seafood restaurants we ever ate at. I had catfish, good light breading and so good. My husband had seafood platter. It had everything on it and he loved it. Our waitress was so nice and great service.

11/09/2021 - Mr.Mrs Graybeal
Visited Saturday evening 11-8-2021. Our server was very busy but greeted us with a smile and was able to accommodate us with our order of half fried and half broiled Flounder and Popcorn shrimp. Food delivered quickly and delicious and service was outstanding and professional. We loved it and will be back and we will ask for Chris.

06/15/2021 - Seifert Family
Was there on Saturday night 6-12-21. It was our first time visiting. Server Chris was very patient with our questions and her suggestions were spot on. We loved the food ,service and the hospitality! We will be back soon! Thanks Chris.

01/18/2021 - Bryan
Since they reopened they seems to be better than they used to. Slow sometimes but no too bad. We eat there several times a month.

10/31/2020 - Wright
Don't eat here. The food is disgusting. Our fish was like rubber. The scalps were dry. Oysters were very dry. Shrimp was ok. Waitress was nice but slow on drinks. The blonde greeter was none to pleasant. The tarter sauce also sits on the table all day with the spout open. The amount of salt they put on our food was unreal. My wife and I felt horrible the rest of the night.

08/25/2019 - MenuPix User
Great food!

05/22/2019 - MenuPix User
Excellent Food and Service.

04/20/2013 - charlie isaacs
i heard they might reopen i hope so i miss mayflowers good food.

03/09/2013 - charlie isaacs
real good food but they shut down so no mayflower.

05/04/2009 - seafoodlover
This restaurant has re-opened under new management with larger portions, good food and friendly service.