Tony Maronni's

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

N63w23951 Main St
Sussex, WI 53089

Phone: (262) 820-8669

Website

Neighborhood: Sussex

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.

Restaurant Photos

See More Photos

 See All Photos

See All Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Tony Maronni's

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Tony Maronni's

Write a Review

  4.1 stars - Based on 16 votes

#1 out of 20 restaurants in Sussex

#1 of 1 Italian in Sussex

5 star				8 votes	50%
4 star				5 votes	31%
3 star				1 votes	6%
2 star				1 votes	6%
1 star				1 votes	6%

Top Reviews of Tony Maronni's

03/25/2024 - MenuPix User

06/13/2023 - Andrea
I have to say I think this is probably the worst pizza I have ever had. I placed our order online at 6:05pm with no problem, simply order XL pizza, w/pepperoni & extra sauce. Was given a time for the pizza to be ready of 6:50PM. I got to the restaurant at 6:40, thinking maybe pizza could be ready early. I give my name and was told they hadn't even started on my pizza yet but would get working on it. Pizza is finally ready at 7:05. We get the pizza home and there is barely any sauce on it let alone extra sauce and maybe a handful of cheese and pepperonis. Should also mention it was overcooked. With all the good reviews I guess they could have been having an off night but I won't be back to find out.

07/12/2020 - Nino
Great little pizzeria. Crispy thin crust with the cup and crispy pepperoni 🍕

03/04/2017 - Luigi Lombardi
Being from Sicily I know a few things about pizza.I heard about Tony's from a friend of mine and said that this place had decent high quality pizza. So my wife and I stopped in on a Friday afternoon and the place looked like the places back home in Sicily. Our waitress was super nice and explained that if we have pizza we get a house salad and some fresh Italian bread with some special butter that comes with the bread, both were delicious. We ordered the St. Anthony pizza, it had Italian sausage, Calabrese Salami, Sopressata, roasted garlic and fire roasted peppers. The crust was cracker thin and flavorful just the way it should be. I would highly suggest that anybody that wants high quality service and a true Sicilian dining experience to give Tony Maronni's and try. You will not be disappointed.

02/19/2016 - Sal P.
Nice place. Friendly staff, and a lovely dining room. Had there Baked cheese dish and that was enjoyed by all. Pizza was good, crispy and flavorful. Bathroom was clean and the little mints that they have are to die for. To bad we live in Chicago, we would certainly be here more often.

12/24/2015 - Mario Gimignani
Had there pizza of the month a few times now over the past year and I'm very impressed of the authenticity of there pizzas. I grew up in southern Italy and have to say that Tony's really do have the best authentic pies this side of the pond. If you don't try there pizzas your really missing out on a little gem here in Sussex. Keep up the good work Tony.

12/18/2015 - Omw2fyb
So I went to Tony's for dinner tonight.. 1st off walking into this place smelled like Chuck E Cheese's. The kitchen and dining room didn't look very clean. The food was over priced and it didn't satisfy my hunger. The sauce left a weird after taste and my thin crust was not crispy at all. They also need to teach there phone person better customer service. Not friendly or inviting at all. Probably wouldn't waste my time with them again.