I Love Ny Pizza

Popular Menu Items

• 2 Slices & Drink
• Two slices of pizza with assorted toppings, including pepperoni, mushrooms, olives, bell peppers, onions, and pineapple, paired with a drink.
• 2 Slice & French Fries
• A variety of two pizza slices with toppings including olives, mushrooms, peppers, onions, and tomatoes, served with a side of crispy French fries.
• 2 Slices & Salad
• A variety of pizza slices topped with ingredients like tomatoes, red onions, bell peppers, olives, mushrooms, and green onions, served with a fresh mixed salad.
• Cheese Burger With French Fries
• Juicy beef patty topped with melted cheese, fresh lettuce, tomato, red onion, and pickles, served with crispy French fries.
• Stromboli With Drink
• Golden-brown baked Stromboli filled with savory meats, melted cheese, and herbs, served with a side of marinara sauce.

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

28 N Front St
Wilmington, NC 28401

Phone: (910) 762-7628

Website

Neighborhood: Downtown

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Sun-Wed: 10:30am-10pm Thurs-Sat: 10:30am-3am

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for I Love Ny Pizza

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for I Love Ny Pizza

Write a Review

  4.4 stars - Based on 48 reviews

#42 out of 266 restaurants in Downtown

#2 of 10 Pizza in Downtown

5 star				31 reviews	65%
4 star				11 reviews	23%
3 star				3 reviews	6%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				3 reviews	6%

Top Reviews of I Love Ny Pizza

02/09/2025 - mr K.
The pizza here is fantastic, with huge slices that remind me of New York. The friendly staff and lively atmosphere make it a perfect late-night stop, where I've even made friends while waiting in line.

06/04/2024 - Jessi O.
Awesome

02/18/2013 - Thomas
I love their pizza, I eat there quite often. I highly recommend ordering a X-large pepperoni and extra cheese pie, its amazing. To the person that said the prices were not what they are advertised as, perhaps you went late at night. Sun-wed they arent open late and thurs-sat they are open until 3am. From 11pm-3am they have a 'late night menu' that is more expensive.

08/10/2012 - jacob
Best pizza ever

04/23/2012 - Keely H.
My boyfriend and I stopped in looking forward to some tasty pizza yesterday. We each ordered two slices of plain cheese pizza. We started eating and noticed that the pizza tasted burnt and disgusting. My boyfriend took our second pieces back up to the counter to tell the staff that the pizza was burned and we would like two new, fresh slices. They told us that that taste was the "original crust flavor" and would not give us two fresh pieces that were not burned. Original crust flavor?? You must always burn your pizza then.. I am completely disgusted with the pizza here and even more disgusted with the lack of customer service that was shown. I will never eat from this I Love NY Pizza again and I will never recommend that anyone else eat there either. Rude service and crappy pizza.

PS: Want to know what you've been missing out on? Go to I Love NY Pizza in Raleigh. Now that's great pizza.

04/23/2012 - Jared
Went with my girlfriend at dinner time and got two pieces of cheese pizza each. We sat down to eat and the pizza was dry and stiff as a board, cracked all over when you folded it and had a bad burnt taste, we ate the first piece out of courtesy but the second one was the same way so i nicely asked the two guys if we could get two different slices, that it was not fresh and tasted burnt. He Informed me that it WAS fresh and NOT burnt and would not replace two pitiful slices of pizza. I know what burnt bread tastes like. And i ate twice a week at the new york pizza in raleigh and it is superb. but this one was a huge dissapointment Aweful service and way to do business, wont go back unless im in the mood for some really bad pizza and really rude people.

11/13/2010 - kim
Their prices online are not what they charge when you get there.. much higher!!! Not cool.

10/13/2009 - sita
This pizza is delicious.WOW! Now that i live here, we can go all the time. I hear the white pizza is a great seller. Try the rio rancho well done. This is very yummy. While your waiting, look out the window and you'll feel like your in N.Y.

08/01/2009 - The Sausage king of Chicago
Un-friggen-believable.....

Tastes like that place when you come out from an afternoon at The Bing in Jersey.....


Best Gabagool in da south....

Aaaeeyyyy.....

03/31/2009 - MenuPix User
Great Pizza and wonderful staff to help you.

10/31/2008 - MenuPix User
I love this pizza! Just like NY

10/11/2008 - Amberl9
The pizza is great. it its the only place in Wilmington that has pizza like New York.

09/05/2008 - MenuPix User
Only accept cash!!!!!

07/03/2007 - Downtown Resident
Great Pizza!! Truly NY Style. Best in Town in my opinion.