64% say Yum
14 people voted
64% say Yum
14 people voted
People Who Viewed This Also Viewed
First Avenue Diner ($)
Diner, American, Breakfast, Sandwiches
Rounders Too Pizza ($$$)
American, Pizza, Sandwiches, Subs
Big-Top Drive In ($)
Burgers, Sandwiches, American
Sam's Pizzeria ($)
Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
| Add Photo
Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.
Mon-Sat: 6:30am - 8pm, Sun: 6:30am - 2pm
Credit Cards Accepted
Good for Kids
$ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
Reviews of Pie Pan
08/26/2014 - jc
I have not worked there. polish sausage was a weiner ,gravy had no flavor. I expected a home cooked meal, but that's far from the meal I received. 6.75 for the meal, 8.99 for wolfs. no brainer, my grandparents ate there 20 years ago, don't know what happened but it was a huge disappointment. please owners take pride again get busy fixing your problems. fresh is cheaper than frozen , looks like you have nice ovens that are used for storage. your days are limited if you refuse to improve food quality.
07/26/2013 - Dawn Myers
I think the food is awesome and the servers are great. All the Bad reviews that were placed were placed from ex-employees who probably ended up getting fired, as you can see they cannot spell, thus showing the type of person they are! Eat at The PIE PAN! At least try it and rate for yourself :)
09/12/2012 - customer
pie pan food is the farthest from the home cooked homemade food they are so ready to say it is. I have personally seen the kitchen walk in and line. the frozen (not homemade) food goes from the cooler (uncovered) to a stove to a microwave to your plate, never mind the disgusting frozen food you are being to told is homemade think about the cross contamination of it sitting in the cooler with raw chicken and no date add to that i have seen raw meat still make it from there to your plate and people eat half there meal before realizing they have been eating raw chicken. then you decide to try there famous desserts made straight for cake mix boxes or frozen pie shells with instant pudding dumped on top sure sounds homemade. once you get threw this wonderfully charming homemade meal you move on to the cashier to pay your overpriced bill if you can find her that is and you are received with rudeness just as I'm sure you are by your waitress as I've realized all the friendly ones have been fired or chased off! both the owner Libby and her #1 manager are said to be good christian people as per my knowledge of Christianity a true christian does not lie as they do to the IRS, health dept, employees and most importantly you the customers. i hope you think twice before you think bout eating there, eating there again, or letting your loved ones eat there.
11/30/2010 - Kathy
I've been to this restaurant many times. I've always had very good service, and the food was great. I will keep going back.
10/16/2010 - p brown
POOR, will not go again. Ordered grilled tenderloin sandwich that looked and tasted like hamburg. The order was cup of soup and sandwich and price shown on the menu. Bill however, was sandwich, soup and drink. Asked at the register why charge when menu showed together and WOW what a rude lady she was. IF this is the way they this lady handles questions she needs to be in back doing dishes. We have never been treated so rude for asking a question. Had to ask her to please just ring up the bill. Never will step foot in this rude place again. They need to understand that if you run off your customer you doors will close. I will be telling as many as I can to avoid them.
I grew up in Princeton, IN and love taco tierra! The food and service there was always amazing but the Evansville location is far from that, and if a...
The food was just as I remember BUT - GET RID OF THAT NASTY KETCHUP and get some good stuff. That will keep people away. We bring our own!...
Scandals Night Club
What a dump. ...
12 of us went night before Valentine's - not sure what the problem was.
Service HORRIBLE, Food Horrible and remark for lacking in both departme...
Me and my friend ordered spaghetti and drinks and a brownie first off the spaghetti was microwaved and the bread was cold and plain plus the sweet tea...