70% say Yum
168 people voted
70% say Yum
168 people voted
People Who Viewed This Also Viewed
Delphi Diner Restaurant ($$)
Diner, American, Breakfast, Sandwiches
Pudgie's Famous Chicken ($$$)
Monte Di Procida Ristorante & Pizzeria ($$)
Green City Kitchen ($$)
| Add Photo
This restaurant has closed. If this restaurant is open or has reopened, just let us know.
Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.
Credit Cards Accepted
Good for Kids
$ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
Reviews of Carousel Diner
07/02/2014 - James jack
Food was disgusting, made me sick for hours afterwards and gave me terrible diarrhea!! Very dissapainted.. The place looks like it was made in the 1800s, never going back. Only went there because it was so close to my house. Would not reccomend to anyone, maybe a few rats or possums would enjoy this place!!
11/30/2012 - ansel
Worst diner ever worst service horriblly rude and cocky owners dirtiest place ive ever seen I actuallynsaw the cockroaches running away screaming
11/16/2010 - Frank, bayshore, ny
My wife and I go to this diner and think the service is outstanding and the panini portobello sandwich was the best I have ever eaten. It may be a small diner but it excels with the chef and the waitresses. We haven't found any good diners in the shore area. This surpases them all.
03/27/2010 - Nick
My friends and I all decided to go to this diner one night. One of our friends had ate before so he did not order anything, He was told that if he did not order anything he had to leave. This "new policy" was absurde and our party of eight left and will never go back. Diners are a dime a dozen and that was one bad egg.
09/19/2009 - Gayle
My family and I only go there because it is very close by my house. Usually it is ok food...just ok. My husband's dinner was actually pretty good tonight. We ordered a 9.99 special that came with soup, entree , drink and dessert. Then after he ate and asked to take his dessert home they told him you are not allowed to take dessert home. So my husband stuffed down his dessert because we had paid for it. My 9 year old daughter could not finish her meal and was very full. We asked if there was something she could bring home for dessert, even a cookie. We were told you are not allowed to take dessert home and a cookie is not included anyway. We just felt it wasn't clearly written that you can't take home dessert. We have never been to a place where you can't take home your dessert unless it was an all you can eat buffet. It doesn't make sense.
Just think it is "penny wise and pound foolish". So over probably a fifty cent dessert we will never go there again. No wonder we were the only people in the diner at 9:00 on a Saturday night!!
09/12/2009 - Umberto JuevosCaliente
My deluxe burger was great! The beef was delectably fresh. Every savory bite followed suit to the next. My tasebuds were sent on an uncontrollable roller coaster of flavor. Mid way through my chewing I needed to use the bathroom. So I stopped what I was doing and went.
Let me tell you boys and girls....
My experience in the bathroom was nothing shy of life changing. 10 STARS! And heres why!!!
I feel privleged to have had the opportunity to have my tight buns grace their teal 1975 American Standard Cadet Signature Series toilet. The decor was nice. The walls looked as thought they havent been painted in 50 years and mold and absbestos oozed from the crackling and peeling faded yellow paint. There was a dirty pair of panties stuck to the wall and previously used toilitries graced every inch of the floor of the 4 x 4 bathroom. While pondering and forcing out a good size loaf I gazed downward and noticed
yellow stains around the tiles of the foot of the toilet. Truthfully this added so warmth to my experience. There were moments where I felt as though I was wisked away making poo poo on a remote tripocal island.
There was a womans number etched into the toilet paper holder; so i called her and boy did I have a good time! After my brown fecal chunks left my southern most orifice , I was able to experience wiping with the power of a one ply toilet paper that scraped the hairs off my tender cheeks.
OKAY ENOUGH RAMBLING!
I LOVE THE CAROUSEL DINER!!!!
08/09/2009 - Kristen west islip ny
After a long night with my friends......it was great to find a diner that was open!The carousel diner was great.The waitress and the food was just what i needed at the end of the night. Me and my friends are definately going to go back again!!!!!!
doesn't GET ANY BETTER!...
(Glen Cove, NY)
Great food, great waitresses. Love the Uncle Ang omelet ...
(East Islip, NY)
Actually less than one star. We went there this afternoon for an early Father's Day dinner, got seated, and not one waitress server, manager, or empl...
(East Islip, NY)
We love Rizzo's the food is fantastic, and the portions are plentiful. My grandson is there every day he love Rizzo's . Joe is a a great guy. If yo...
(Massapequa Park, NY)
glad it's gone...chain smokers inside..back room with lousy band inside...it was not a good time!...