Sweet Tomato's

Reported as permanently closed. Find something similiar nearby.

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

15 Grand Ave
Shelter Island, NY 11964

Phone: (631) 749-4114

Website

Neighborhood: Shelter Island

Update Listing

Hours

This restaurant has been reported as permanently closed. Click here if it has reopened.

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

*This restaurant has closed. If this restaurant is open or has reopened, just let us know.

Sweet Tomato's has been an island's favorite for 13 years now. The season 2015 marks a new step in the life of the restaurant; James and Mary Rando have brought Adrien Angelvy as the restaurant manager, formerly from La Goulue in NYC. The real move has occurred in the newly renovated kitchen; world acclaimed Chef Alfredo Alvarez who has been friend with the Randos for a long time, jumped on board as consultant chef and has created a traditional seasonal italian menu that is raising the bar. New menu being executed by Chef de cuisine Oscar Del Rosario, former alumni of Jean-Georges. Pizzas are now served not only at the bar but also in the dining room, fresh homemade pastas, daily special and other delicacies will fit everyone's taste. The wine list has been curated by our sommelier, and includes Italian, American and local wines.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Sweet Tomato's

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Sweet Tomato's

Write a Review

  3.8 stars - Based on 5 votes

5 star				1 votes	20%
4 star				2 votes	40%
3 star				2 votes	40%
2 star				0 votes	0%
1 star				0 votes	0%

Top Reviews of Sweet Tomato's

08/06/2011 - Catherine Wachs
Great, professional service, pretty room and nice, front porch dining, excellent food. The new owners recused it from a long slide, and now it is quite good.