Shelter Island Restaurant Guide

• 
  Vine Street Cafe ($$$)
  

  Cafe, Sandwiches, American New, Italian, Asian Fusion • Menu Available

  41 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-3210 (631) 749-3210

  Write a Review!
• 
  Salt Waterfront Bar & Grill ($$)
  

  American, Gastropubs, Bar Food • Menu Available

  63 S Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-5535 (631) 749-5535

  Write a Review!
• 
  Shelter Island Craft Brewery ($$)
  

  Breweries • Menu Available

  55 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-5977 (631) 749-5977

  Write a Review!
• 
  Commander Cody's Seafood ($$)
  

  Seafood, Barbecue • Menu Available

  41 Smith St, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-1851 (631) 749-1851

  Write a Review!
• 
  Maria's Kitchen ($)
  

  Mexican • Menu Available

  55 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-5450 (631) 749-5450

  Write a Review!
• 
  18 Bay Restaurant ($$$)
  

  Italian • Menu Available

  23 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-0053 (631) 749-0053

  Write a Review!
• 
  The Islander ($$)
  

  American • Menu Available

  63 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-1998 (631) 749-1998

  Write a Review!
• 
  Tuck Shop ($$)
  

  Australian, Ice Cream, Yogurt • Menu Available

  75 Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-1548 (631) 749-1548

  Write a Review!
• 
  Kyle's ($$)
  

  Bakery, Bar, Diner, Breakfast • Menu Available

  27 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-0579 (631) 749-0579

  Write a Review!
• 
  Shelter Island Slice ($)
  

  Pizza, Sandwiches • Menu Available

  3 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-9292 (631) 749-9292

  Write a Review!
• 
  Shelter Island Seafood ($)
  

  Seafood, Seafood Markets • Menu Available

  87 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 765-8181 (631) 765-8181

  Write a Review!
• 
  Leon 1909 ($)
  

  Italian, French • Menu Available

  29 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island Heights, NY
  (631) 749-9123 (631) 749-9123

  Write a Review!
• 
  Bella Vita Pizza ($$)
  

  Pizza • Menu Available

  53 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-5463 (631) 749-5463

  Write a Review!
• 
  The Eccentric Bagel ($)
  

  Bagels • Menu Available

  25 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-5363 (631) 749-5363

  Write a Review!
• 
  Island Boatyard ($$)
  

  American • Menu Available

  65 S Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-3333 (631) 749-3333

  Write a Review!
• 
  Planet Bliss ($$)
  

  American • Menu Available

  23 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-0053 (631) 749-0053

  Write a Review!
• 
  Cafe 27 ($) - Closed
  

  American, Cafe, Sandwiches • Menu Available

  27 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-2727 (631) 749-2727

  Write a Review!
• 
  Dory ($$) - Closed
  

  American • Menu Available

  185 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-4300 (631) 749-4300

  Write a Review!
• 
  Sweet Tomato's ($$$) - Closed
  

  Italian, Pizza • Menu Available

  15 Grand Ave, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-4114 (631) 749-4114

  Write a Review!
• 
  Piesano's ($$$) - Closed
  

  Pizza, Italian, Catering • Menu Available

  3 North Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-9292 (631) 749-9292

  Write a Review!
• 
  Eagle Deli ($) - Closed
  

  Deli, Sandwiches • Menu Available

  25 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-5363 (631) 749-5363

  Write a Review!
• 
  Olde Country Inn ($) - Closed
  

  American, Southern, Cafe • Menu Available

  11 Stearns Point Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-1633 (631) 749-1633

  Write a Review!
• 
  Pat & Steve's Family Restaurant ($) - Closed
  

  American • Menu Available

  63 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-1998 (631) 749-1998

  Write a Review!
• 
  Bobs Restaurant ($$) - Closed
  

  Seafood • Menu Available

  87 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-0830 (631) 749-0830

  Write a Review!
• 
  Michael Anthony's At Dering ($$) - Closed
  

  American • Menu Available

  65 S Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-3460 (631) 749-3460

  Write a Review!
• 
  Cannery Row Cafe At Alfreds ($$) - Closed
  

  Cafe • Menu Available

  63 Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-2516 (631) 749-2516

  Write a Review!
• 
  Shelter Island Bake Shop ($$) - Closed
  

  American • Menu Available

  27 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-2717 (631) 749-2717

  Write a Review!
• 
  Island Cafe ($) - Closed
  

  Cafe, Sandwiches • Menu Available

  63 S Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-3355 (631) 749-3355

  Write a Review!
• 
  On Shore ($$) - Closed
  

  American • Menu Available

  13 Winthrop Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-2300 (631) 749-2300

  Write a Review!
• 
  Primo Pizza & Restaurant ($) - Closed
  

  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches • Menu Available

  53 Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-2732 (631) 749-2732

  Write a Review!
• 
  Two Eds ($$) - Closed
  

  American • Menu Available

  1 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
  (631) 749-0261 (631) 749-0261

  Write a Review!