Carmella's Italian Kitchen
88% say Yum
8 people voted
88% say Yum
8 people voted
People Who Viewed This Also Viewed
Carmella's Italian Steak & Seafood ($$$)
Steakhouse, Italian, Seafood
Mariner's Landing ($$)
Carmella's Italian Kitchen ($$$)
American, Barbecue, Burgers
| Add Photo
Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.
Hours: Add Hours
Accepts Credit Cards
$ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
Reviews of Carmella's Italian Kitchen
08/02/2010 - Rich J.
We were visiting Olcott on 7/30/10 and we chose to have dinner at Carmella's Italian and Mexican Restaurant. Their menu offers both Italian and Mexican dishes. The service during our dinner was excellent, the food was incredible, the weather was nice, and the view of Lake Ontario from their outdoor deck was a perfect compliment to an excellent meal. My wife had a large steak wrap that she said was delicious and really outstanding. I had a large portion of hand-made lasagna that was clearly some of the best lasagna that I've ever eaten - ANYWHERE. The lasagna was moist and the flavors of the meat, cheese, and sauce all blended together perfectly to make the dish so delicious. We had an order of hand-made cornbread that was well beyond any cornbread that you find in a typical restaurant. For desert, we both chose a large slice of homemade carrot cake that was simply some of the best carrot cake we had anywhere. We talked with both the new chef and the owner and learned from them that much of the food (including the lasagna) is all hand-made, as are the deserts. The prices are very reasonable for the large portions and excellent quality. Everything was perfect and we'd definitely eat there again. We dine out a lot during our travels, and I don't recommend any restaurant unless our experience there is a good one. If you appreciate quality food at fair prices, I honestly think you'll enjoy Carmella's.
10/27/2009 - cindy and jim
This place was wonderful. The seafood bisque is to die for. And the music and views are totally awsome.!! For the money and entertainment!! Well worth every penny.
Wide Waters Drive In
Highly and ridiculously overpriced! Better visit the bank before going there! Time from ordering to getting your food frustratingly LONG !! Fries we...
Park Place Restaurant
Great food, great service, and the home made potato salad is awesome...
Not happy with the price of tap water asked for water with my meal they give me a glass of water and then charge $1.99 for it will not be eating ther...
Extremely reasonable and big portions! Great family place. I go there frequently!...
John and Lonnie's Pizza and More
Good food and good prices. Been there twice so far and this may be my new go-to plzzeria if they continue as they are now...