Reviews for Yetty's Pizza

02/29/2024 - MenuPix User

01/19/2024 - MenuPix User

12/26/2023 - MenuPix User

12/10/2023 - MenuPix User

11/09/2023 - MenuPix User

08/30/2022 - John Glogowski
Ben going to yettys for r decades lately been going down Hill depends whose cooking Got a Paul's original good pie if it's made right got food aweek ago. Live 3 blocks away said ready in 20 min got there in 15min. Pick up pie got home it was ice cold TERRIBLE!!CALLEDthem back told man on phone what's up...he wellI cooked it in the oven and hung up on me. DOWN HILL MAN!!!

08/19/2018 - Allison L.
Food is inconsistent.

01/14/2018 - oldtimer
Me and Yetty.s go way back to the early sixties when we went there for the best pizza around. Very disappointed when we took our grandson for a farewell dinner last week before he entered the Military. The meal was fair but service was worse. I had to ask refill of water. Dirty dishes were still on the table when we left. We decided not to linger even though it was our last night with our grandson for several weeks. It seems she was more interested in the young guy at the bar than tending to her duties. We still tipped 20% even though she didn't deserve it .We won't return. We thought the food would be better since the quality of the take -out pizza has gone to the dumps.
Paul Yetty would be very disappointed.

10/05/2017 - pete worlock
NO CONSISTENCY IN THEIR FOOD. CHICKEN STRIP SALAD, SOMETIMES IT COMES WITH ONIONS ,AND SOMETIMES NOT. SEVERAL TIMES IT WAS ALWAYS MISSING SOME ITEM. OLIVES, CUCUMBERS,OR SKIMPY ON LETTUCE. SOMETIMES PANINI BREAD BURNED. THEY LOST OUR BUSINESS, WE USE TO STOP 3 OR 4 TIMES A WEEK. BYE BYE

08/18/2017 - Molly Cee
Friday haddock - menu stated "broiled, Italian style, parmigiana, breaded". It was baked with some bland tomato sauce on it. We ate maybe half. Blandest haddock ever. What has happened to Yetty's ? We won't go back.

03/11/2017 - Martha
My husband and I have been eatng yettys pizza for over 50 years and it was always one of our favorites but recently we have had 2 pizzas from yettys and the sausage tastes spoiled. In fact the last one we scraped the sauce off the meat and ate only the crust and sauce. We won't be buying another one again.i

11/27/2015 - K. Stack
We had our rehearsal dinner here for our wedding and my inlaws are still talking about the amazing food. We order Yetty's every time we come up from Baltimore because there is no place like it. The food is great and the service is just as awesome! We are currently debating on how many pounds of the creamy southwest wings we need to order to feed everyone at the house.

01/25/2015 - Hope
Never the same sometimes good sometimes bad better to eat in then to order out

12/23/2014 - alex
LOVE IT LOVE IT .GREAT FOOD,NICE QUIET PLACE TO EAT

10/20/2014 - C.Brown
II love Yetty's! My cousin and I visit once a week,and are never disappointed.Great food,friendly service.Try the linguine with fresh clams!Wonderful!

06/23/2014 - Wayne Lenig
I have been eating Yetty's pizza since the early 1960s. It still tastes the same and it is one of a very few restaurants where you can get authentic Mohawk Valley "tomato pie" - like it was made in the 1920s and 30s. The secret is the sauce is actually a marinara, added after the pizza is cooked. This is no pale imitation "New York Pizza" or "Chicago style pizza" It is the home-grown tradition, and in my opinion, par excellence!

10/28/2013 - Christine Krauss
Omg this fried dough with glaze on it is out of this world! I order it off the dessert menu as a appetizer. It could almost be a meal if you like fried dough. Ask for the dough with their famous glaze to go on it. The fried dough I actually worth traveling over an hour for like I do. The pizza is also the best I ever had with homemade sausage yum! The only disappointment I had was when I ordered their BLT sub. They really skimped on the tomatoes and the bacon. It was a big sub roll with two tiny tomatoes and two strips of bacon. It's like c'mon really, I felt like I should have just ordered the sub roll with mayo and lettuce..It really is the best for pizza and fried dough!

08/19/2013 - c.mohawk
a very nice waitstaff..great food...reasonable prices