New York Pizza & Pasta
94% say Yum
162 people voted
94% say Yum
162 people voted
People Who Viewed This Also Viewed
Ronnie's Cafe ($)
American, Italian, Barbecue, Soul Food
Da Vinci's Ristorante Italiano ($$)
Italian, Steakhouse, Seafood, Pizza
The Red Tomato and Wine Restaurant ($$)
New York Pizza & Pasta ($$)
Italian, Pasta, Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
| Add Photo
Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.
Credit Cards Accepted
Good for Kids
$ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
Reviews of New York Pizza & Pasta
09/07/2016 - Mo
My family has been eating at New York Pizza since they opened 25 years ago, They are by far the best in town!!!
I have never been disappointed! I drive 20 miles one way to eat their excellent food.
09/06/2016 - Richie
This is by far the best pizza place I miss it dearly some of the best calzones and stuff Pizza I've ever tasted immense proportions without a shadow of a doubt I can say with confidence this is beyond New York Pizza mouth watering Pizza try a New York stuffed pizza you will be impressed my favorite is the meat lovers or you can get the vegetarian Anderson South Carolina you are privileged to have this in your town!!!
02/10/2016 - Janey
The. Best. Ever.
01/29/2015 - Bob
I'm from Oceanside NY. Their pizza is as good or better then pizza back home. Maybe there were some screw-ups but things happen. The only better pizza for me is Gino's in Long Beach, NY. I can't believe what some people wrote. It's crazy complaining crap. Maybe they are disliked for other reasons. Pizza is supposed to have a lot of olive oil and the cheese is always loose when it is very hot. Be patient and let it cool.
this is New York
01/16/2015 - Norman
New to the area, tried out the pizza. Dough on the end of the crust was raw when you bit into it, sauce lacked flavor, and the sausage...God only knows what kind or form of meat it was. I called it mystery meat. Because it's a mystery what animal it came from. Never again. Frozen pizza is way better.
12/26/2014 - Becky
Just tried to order delivery for first time, live 4.5 miles from this place and the won't deliver to us. Just lost a potential frequent customer!
01/10/2014 - Sandra Burdette
We have been eating New York since they have come to this area. It is high quality food. The stuff crust pizza, calzone,and lasagna are our favorites but have never gotten anything I did not like here.
07/10/2013 - James C.
This place is really good! The pizzas are tasty. The owner is always their on Friday night making my pizza. He's makes the best stuffed pizza in this area hands down. We try and go every week. If you come here you must try the Calzone, stuffed pie, and their pasta.
07/10/2013 - Timothy Wallace
Love their pasta. Pizza is good! Must try the Chicago deep dish pie they offer.
12/15/2012 - billy
We have been customers since the last location behind Brewsters..the restaurant has gone steadily downhill since then. I ordered a large cheese pizza about 6 months ago and it was good, but we stopped in this past week and got 2 individual cheese pizza's which just sucked. They were loaded with so much cheese that it was sliding down to the middle of the plate because it was so hot.
Besides all that, the place is filthy, outdated, the buffet is wide open where the wind can blow all kinds of crap over the food...just a very unpleasant experience all the way around. I am sick and tired of getting ripped off at food establishments that I'm basically done..it was $12.93 for that crap, no more...NY pizza lost a customer here.
05/09/2009 - The Manee's
The food sucks the chicken tasted like nothing and the fried tasted dry ...
J Peter Grill & Bar
Food was good but nothing that would just knock your socks off. The main complaint I have was the noise level. Extremely high noise. Difficult to car...
A friend and I came to Schlotzsky's for lunch at 12:45. After we ordered, we were given a number and we sat down. 20 minutes passed and still our orde...
Mishima Express Japanese
I love Mishima! It's my go-to lunch spot, my usual waitress is so friendly and the food is amazing! If you haven't been, you have to go! ...