Follow Us

Donny's New York Pizza

($$) - Closed
View Menu
22 Main St
Winooski, VT 05404 (Map & Directions)
Phone: (802) 655-7888

Menus People Viewed Nearby

Papa Frank's Italian Restaurant ($)
Italian, Subs, Pizza, Sandwiches

Waf's Westside Deli-Pizza ($)
Sandwiches, Subs, Pizza, Salads

Misery Loves Company ($$)
American, Burgers, Sandwiches, Subs

Tiny Thai Restaurant ($$)

Additional Dining Info

Yes - all day delivery

Accepts Credit Cards


Good for Kids


Full Bar


Price Point
$$ $ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)


Outdoor Seats


Add Hours

Restaurant Description

*This restaurant has closed. If this restaurant is open or has reopened, just let us know.

Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.

Restaurant Photos

camera_icon | Add Photo

Write a Review for Donny's New York Pizza

Share Your
star1 star2 star3 star4 star5
Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Top Reviews of Donny's New York Pizza

review_stars 11/10/2015 - breanna
food amazing cheap prices very nice people faimly friendly and they care a lot about there community

review_stars 11/03/2015 - Nina
Do NOT order from this place!!! Your pizza will take over an hour and a half to be delivered COLD and the person who answered the phone on Tuesday evening 11-3-15 is not customer oriented. In fact, he is not nice at all. Never ever order from them!

review_stars 10/11/2015 - suzanne
did not read the reviews befor ordering..bog mistake..chic parm is thin sliced unbreaded chic on roll with sauce and cheese(?) ...EEWWW...AND my baked ziti with meatballs had no meatballs and was sprinkled with a ton of oregano...way more than anyone would deem necessary...double eewww

review_stars 08/23/2015 - DTel
Just ordered chicken parm for delivery.....thinly sliced unbreaded chicken over stale pasta, barely any sauce. I threw it in garbage. Never ordering here again....second time ordering, pizza sucks too.. Should have learned first time after pizza...... Take New York off your name....!!!

review_stars 06/20/2015 - Annymous
Pizza was cold and salty very little sauce on the pizza will not order here again and salad had very little dressing. Called to have it delivered not any more its the worst pizza I ever had.

review_stars 03/23/2015 - Goggles
Absolutely love this place, I could sit here for 1/2 an hour writing about how great this place is but instead, you should become a regular, and discover how awesome Donny's is for yourself.

review_stars 03/21/2015 - Winooski Local
The food is pretty good, especially the Sicilian Pizza, and some of the hot subs. The main problem with this place is the general attitude of the employee(s). The owner and wife are rather pleasant, and always willing to help you out, but the others.... Downright rude. From throwing your change back onto the counter instead of handing it to you, to hanging up on you before you've finished ordering, this place needs an overhaul. You're employees of a pizza restaurant, where are you getting this bizarre self-entitlement. You make pizzas, cheer up. Don't be such dicks.

review_stars 02/17/2015 - baylee
I tried Donny's pizza tonight for the first time I ordered 10 minutes to closing and felt really bad but the employees were still very nice and the pizza was delicious!!

review_stars 09/21/2014 - Anonymous
The Sicilian pizzas are delicious, chicken pesto being my favorite. Though I I find the staff there incredibly rude and not worth going even for the good pizza due to outright rude staff. I used to get chicken pesto pizza often and was told that 'you're going to get fat if you keep eating this pizza' by the owner. Having self confidence issues, I was seriously offended by this. I still got his pizza though and he said it again about two weeks later. Never went back. You can also hear the owner yelling at his employees for ridiculous reasons. The good pizza isn't good enough to deal
With such a Negative Atmosphere .

review_stars 03/17/2014 - M. Beaudry
Been in Burlington since November and was pretty disappointed with the quality of the pizza shops that delivered. Finally found Donny's, hands down the best

review_stars 02/06/2014 - You wish you knew
I used to work there. The owner sleeps with every female employee... The other owner is a drug addict. Only redeemable qualities include their mom and her baklava.

review_stars 11/21/2013 - MikeT
Was just about to order food from here and then read all of the horror stories. Thanks but no thanks... I'd rather not deal with rude people.

No joke, you just lost my business.

review_stars 10/17/2013 - Meg
The food is alright, people are the worst. They are rude. Acting like they do you favor when you order food. Donny, you are not the only fxxx restaurant in town. Go back to school and learn some manners. Or your mother is too stupid to teach you to treat people with kindness. Arrogant jack ass.

review_stars 10/05/2013 - christina
I just ordered from them tonight and they were ok on the phone when taken my order...when the delivery guy came he was nice..but after handing me my food he said ur pizza was 22 and change...I handed him 40..I didn't realize til after the guy left he only handed me 8 bucks back...I called them and told them what happened and all they did was make jokes and I could hear everything that they were saying like I couldn't hear them..the guy picked up the phone and said he be right there with the right change...well the delivery guy was rude when he came back and I was rude right back and told him I heard everything on the phone...when he left he gave me the finger

review_stars 08/28/2013 - Denise
Fantastic! We sat outside and the waitress was quick and very friendly! We had the deep dish Greek pizza and a deep dish meat lovers, both were wonderful! The owner came out and chatted with us before dinner. I have to say that they do know how to make you feel right at home, wonderful little town and walking distance from my son's apartment! Will be going back in October and that will be one of my stops!!

review_stars 03/17/2013 - Ryan Legassie
Soo I've been a frequent customer at Donny's for a few months now and have always been satisfied. with the exception of a time or to when I would call and the person on the other end was being very Rude for apparently no reason at all. Any how I went there tonight to get my usual couple slices of pepperoni pizza. When I got to the counter and told the guy what I wanted he surprisingly asked me what was in my plastic bag that I had with me. I thought to myself wtf none of your business man. It was a six pack of Mt. Dew that I had just bought and was wondering how that really mattered to him!! I was getting my food to go not like I was ordering to eat there and drink my own soda which I know u arnt supposed to do. I work at a pizza place and know how it is but anyhow it's not like he asked nicely what I had with me he rudely asked and that alone made me want to just leave and take my business elsewhere but that wasn't even the frosting on the cake!!! The reason why I'm writing this review is, while I was waiting for my food I figured I would use the restroom. I went in and literally had the " Hot Water " running for about 3-4 minutes w/o it even getting Luke warm!! Soo I said scratch that looks like I'm not washing my hand and went to do my buisness! Took the usual 3-5 minutes to do so and before I had the chance to come out of the stall an employee came busting through the door to the tiny one urinal one stall bathroom loudly asking if everything was ok in here and that the boss said you've been in here a very long time! Meanwhile two feet away customers are all eatting there meals over hearing what this guy was saying!! Talk about embarrassing : / I guess if you use there bathroom there's an 8-10 min time limit?? That completely ruined it for me I almost wanted to just leave the slices there that's how discussed I was and will no longer be bringing my buisness there!!

review_stars 01/31/2013 - no one great
use to order all the time was great but the service began to slack and started to deliver wrong order and rude if u give them only 5 dollar tip on a 13$ pizza call back to replace order and they said OK will replace if other one intact and u can give back i believe once food leave a restaurant they can not return it in to the restaurant for heath reason . what u will do with it send it to another customer :)

review_stars 12/28/2012 - Dakota Hill
Ordered delivery from Donny's tonight... My food came on time and was excellent as always. I'd suggest you try their stromboli, best in burlington

review_stars 07/20/2012 - vera
I used to be a good customer but I will not deal with them again.I asked for extra stuff on my food,and I got scammed.A grinder with mostly vegetables and hardly any meat.And a calzone that was all dry.I have complained 2 times and they said they would do better.They have gotten worse.Do not buy from them they will rip you off.

review_stars 06/19/2012 - Mike
The Sicilian is as good as it gets. Pizza rolls are really good too, but it's the Sicilian that keeps me coming back practically every week.

And the family that runs the place is the best - they're always happy to see you. Made me feel like a regular the first time I went in - and now I have been for 8+ years.

review_stars 02/14/2012 - maria
Chicken pesto pizza mama mia belisimo!

review_stars 02/01/2012 - anne
For lunch a Greek salad and a slice is always a great choice for me. The salads are fresh and Delicious!!!

review_stars 01/29/2012 - Matt
Love steak&cheese sub, it's the BOMB
best in town,that goes for buffalo chicken

review_stars 01/29/2012 - Jannet
Stopped in for quick bite with my son, had a few slices, pizza was best i had in a while my son loved it too! Nice atmosphere casual and friendly. We made it back again with family and love the pizza every time!

review_stars 01/08/2012 - anonymous
i worked here before, the owner johnny is a coke head, he's a jerk and harassed me so much to the point where i had to leave. Kosta the other owner is very nice, and cares about the people he serves. the foods good though. johnny just is a jerk, and they still haven't given me my last pay check

review_stars 11/18/2011 - yes!
love this place! friendly, cheap, delicious. what's not to like?

review_stars 08/16/2011 - janet
I called to place an order for delivery and the person on the phone was very rude!I barely told him what I wanted and he kept cutting me off.My grandfather owned an italian restaurant and if we ever answered the phone this way we would not have a job!

review_stars 04/13/2011 - Janet Chase
Fabulous place! Family run by hard working folks that care about good customer service. Food is consistently great. Nice neighborhood kind of place where they remember what you like. And the best pizza in the area. Check it out.

review_stars 12/20/2010 - Demetrios Michaelides
Great place... $2 drafts during the week with best NY pizza

review_stars 08/10/2010 - Io
The folks at Donny's have never let us down. The food is excellent and they treat us like family - but in a good way!

review_stars 07/25/2009 - Jimmy the Greek
As an Authentic Greek I have to rate Donny's Gyro as one of the best I ever had. Who ever makes the Tzatziki sauce deserves my thanks.

review_stars 06/16/2009 - ny pizza expert
mmmmmm it's pretty good pizza for vermont

review_stars 01/18/2009 - MenuPix User
I love this place.

review_stars 01/13/2009 - Nola T
Great crust at a good price. Fast delivery and friendly staff.

review_stars 09/09/2008 - MenuPix User
Family run and operated. Great food especially the Sicilian Pizza. Offers a good selection of Pizza, Salads, Pasta dishes, Subs, and some Greek Specialties. Kids friendly with plenty of space for them. Ideal for sports teams and parties

review_stars 07/08/2008 - JOM
Very nice owners, and the pizza was excellent, reminded of the corner shops in NY in the 60s and 70s when you could walk up to open window and get some of the best pizza ever. Delivery was outstanding, never have had a problem. You won't be dissappointed!

review_stars 04/14/2008 - MenuPix User
Food is great. Delivery drivers are a bit sketchy. The delivery guy rudely asked me "What's smoking?" I was not smoking, and even if I was, it's not his business to judge.

review_stars 04/07/2008 - MenuPix User
I had Donny's catered my company event and it was outstanding. On time, great presentation, good food and very reasonable price.

review_stars 03/18/2008 - MenuPix User
My god if you have not tasted their Sicilian you don't know what Pizza can be. Best kept secret in Burlington. I sat at the Bar and was entertained by the bartender performing bar tricks. Two slices and a beer for less than $7 is a value these days.
The decor was New York but the place is roomy and kids are very welcomed.

review_stars 11/24/2007 - MenuPix User
Hate this place. I hate this place, very rude

review_stars 11/07/2007 - MenuPix User
I Highly reccomended Donny's. I love the Sicilian Pizza and BBQ Chicken. Nice beer selection, owner came to my table and introduce himself. A lot of fun to seat in the Bar. The barman does great bar tricks that are very entertaining.
Great experience.

review_stars 11/06/2007 - MenuPix User
I introduced myself to the Greek Family that owns this place and they treated my like a celebrity. I asked them what to have and they served my a Greek Salad, with imported Feta and Kalamata olives , a Lamb Gyro and a Baklava for desert. I truly enjoyed it.

review_stars 10/30/2007 - MenuPix User
Their Subs are great, especially the Buffalo Chicken.

Their Deep dish pizza is great, crispy where it should be and just plain tasty.

Go there for a beer and a slice after work, great bartenders who are friendly and always talkative...

Good place to watch sports . . .

Recent Restaurant Reviews

1. Red Square Bar & Grill (Burlington, VT)

It doesn't sound like a good place to go!... read more

2. Pizza Hut (Williston, VT)

I ordered a pizza for delivery from the Williston Vt location added a tip of 4 dollars on to my receipt totaling 23.00 and change.
2 days later... read more

3. Pho K&K (Williston, VT)

Some of the beSt food I've ever light and delicious!!! And the Housin Sriracha sauce was out of this world!!! Excellent excellent excellent!... read more

4. Chef's Corner Cafe Bakery (Williston, VT)

I don't eat out often, although I consider myself a good cook and foodie. My mother and I wanted a special outing so we chose chefs corner. I have eat... read more

5. Aviation Deli & Fine Foods (South Burlington, VT)

$9.12 for a veggie sandwich, ripoff. They also messed up and put things on the sandwich I didn't ask for and didn't include veggies I did ask for. Is ... read more

Burlington Restaurant Guide: See Menus, Ratings and Reviews for Restaurants in Burlington and Vermont
United States Restaurant Guide:
AK | AL | AR | AZ | DE | CA | CT | CO | FL | GA | HI | ID | IL | IN | IA | KS | KY | LA | MD | ME | MA | MI | MN | MS | MO | MT | NC | ND | NE | NV | NH | NJ | NM | NY | OH | OK | OR | PA | RI | SC | SD | TN | TX | UT | VT | VA | WA | WV | WI | WY
Canadian Major Cities and Provinces:
Alberta | British Columbia | Manitoba | New Brunswick | Newfoundland | Nova Scotia | Ontario | Prince Edward Island | Quebec | Saskatchewan | Yukon | Calgary | Edmonton | Montreal | Ottawa | Regina | Saskatoon | Toronto | Vancouver | Victoria | Winnipeg |
Most Popular US City Guides:
Albuquerque | Amherst | Atlanta | Austin | Baltimore | Boston | Boulder | Brooklyn | Burlington | Cape Cod | Charlotte | Charleston | Chicago | Cincinnati | Cleveland | Columbus | Dallas / Fort Worth | Denver | Detroit | El Paso | Flagstaff | Fort Lauderdale | Fresno | Gulf Coast | Hartford | Hoboken | Honolulu | Houston | Indianapolis | Jackson | Jacksonville | Jersey City | Kansas City | Knoxville | Las Vegas | Long Island | Los Angeles | Louisville | Lowell | Madison | Memphis | Miami | Milwaukee | Minneapolis | Myrtle Beach | Nashua | Nashville | New Orleans | New York City | Oakland | Oklahoma City | Omaha | Orange County | Orlando | Philadelphia | Phoenix | Pittsburgh | Portland | Providence | Raleigh | Reno | Richmond | Riverside | Sacramento | Saint Louis | Salem | Salt Lake City | San Antonio | San Diego | San Francisco | San Jose | Santa Barbara | Santa Fe | Seattle | St. Paul | Tampa | Tucson | Tulsa | Twin Cities | Virginia Beach | Washington, DC | Wilmington | Winston-Salem