Mythical Pizza

Mythical Pizza > Menu View Details

Prices and menu items are subject to change. Contact the restaurant for the most up to date information.
  • Signature Pizzas
  • Yeti's Pepperoni Pie (standard Pepperoni Pizza) $14.00
  • Classic Marinara, Pepperoni and Mozzarella Shreds.
  • E.t. The Extra-toppings Supreme $14.00
  • Classic Marinara, Mozzarella Shreds, Pepperoni, Ham, Sausage, Mushrooms, Red Onions, Green Peppers & Black Olives.
  • Mozzarella Monster (standard Cheese Pizza) $14.00
  • Our Mozzarella Monster is sure to please any appetite! Classic Marinara and Mozzarella Shreds.
  • Quadzilla - King Of Pepperoni $14.00
  • Classic Marinara, SUPER MEGA PEPPERONI (that's a whopping 1/3 lb.). After Bake: Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle & Fine Red Pepper Dusting.
  • Krampus Story $14.00
  • Garlic Oil, Mozzarella Shreds, Whole Milk Ricotta, Steak Crumbles, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Red Onion & Italian Seasoning.
  • Nightmare On Braxie Street $14.00
  • Alfredo, Mozzarella Shreds, Cheddar Shreds, Whole Milk Ricotta, Bacon, White Meat Chicken. After Bake: Fresh Spinach & Honey Sriracha Drizzle.
  • The Alabama White Thang $14.00
  • This LEGENDARY White Pizza includes: Garlic Oil, Fresh Garlic, Mozzarella Shreds, Whole Milk Ricotta, Cherry Tomatoes, Fresh Basil and Seasoned with Loch Ness Garlic and Sea Salt
  • Mothman Strikes Back $14.00
  • Classic Marinara, Mozzarella Shreds, Pepperoni, Ham, Sausage. After Bake: Fresh Spinach & Barbecue Drizzle.
  • Uncle Beak $14.00
  • Ranch, Mozzarella Shreds, White Meat Chicken, Bacon, Red Onion. After Bake: Fresh Spinach & Ranch Drizzle.
  • Stand By Meat (mothman's Fav - Meat Pizza) $14.00
  • Mothman's favorite pizza can be yours too! Classic Marinara, Mozzarella Shreds, Pepperoni, Sausage and Ham±. Also available daily until 8PM as slices!
  • Smokey And The Bigfoot $14.00
  • Barbecue Sauce, Mozzarella Shreds, Cheddar Shreds, White Meat Chicken, Bacon, Green Peppers & Corn. After Bake: Barbecue Drizzle.
  • Flatwood Bueller's Day Off $14.00
  • Classic Marinara, Mozzarella Shreds, Sliced Ham, Pineapple & Jalapeño Peppers.
  • Poultrygeist $14.00
  • Buffalo Sauce, Cheddar Shreds, White Meat Chicken, Banana Peppers & Jalapeño Peppers. After Bake: Ranch Drizzle.
  • Fast Times At Cheeseburger High $14.00
  • Classic Marinara, Cheddar Shreds, Ground Beef, Bacon, Green Pepper, Red Onion & Dill Pickles
  • Sprout-man $14.00
  • Garlic Oil, Mozzarella Shreds, Feta Crumbles, Red Onion, Garlic Roasted Brussels Sprouts. After Bake: Balsamic Glaze.
  • Wyld Shaggyns $14.00
  • Classic Marinara, Mozzarella Shreds, Bleu Cheese, Pepperoni, Sausage, Diced Tomato & Dill Pickles. Truly a unique combination of flavors.
  • Balsamic S.t.r.i.p.e.s. $14.00
  • Classic Marinara, Fresh Mozzarella & Diced Tomato. After Bake: Fresh Spinach & Balsamic Glaze.
  • Close Encounters (of The Veggie Kind) $14.00
  • Alfredo Base, Mozzarella Shreds, Diced Tomatoes, Green Peppers, Marinated Mushrooms, Red Onion, Fresh Basil± and Garlic Roasted Brussels Sprouts±. After Bake: Pesto Sprinkle.
  • Pizza & Salads
  • Your Pizza. Your Way. 13" Full Size Pizza $14.00
  • Customize YOUR PIZZA. YOUR WAY! Select your sauce, cheeses, toppings, edgers and finishes!
  • 7" Personal Pizza - Baby Mothman $9.00
  • Personalize your meal! 7" Personal Pizza fully customized for your taste!
  • Grafton Monster Style Deep Dish 10" Pizza $18.80
  • Our legendary 10" DEEP DISH pizza is full of melty cheese and your choice of toppings & a Loch Ness Garlic Edge, then covered in 8 ounces of Classic Marinara and Parmesan Cheese and baked to perfection!
  • 4" Mini Pizza - Baby Squonk $5.50
  • KIDZ Rejoice! 4" Mini Pizza fully customized for your taste!
  • The Flight Of The Squonks $13.50
  • Select a flight of three of our Signature Pizzas in Baby Squonk's 4" mini form! Please note, while we'll accept special requests to remove certain ingredients, please no substitutions.
  • Your Salad. Your Way. $14.00
  • Our HUGE 64oz Salad Bowls provide you a salad that is always made fresh to order! Our gigantic salad, custom made to your appetite!
  • Snacks
  • Mothman's Pepperoni Roll $8.50
  • The West Virginia staple now has a Cryptid Twist! Our fresh dough is wrapped around a pile of Pepperoni and Mozzarella Shreds, coated in Garlic Oil, and then baked to a golden brown, and dusted with our secret Parmesan and Garlic topping - served with a Dipperzzz of Choice!
  • Jersey Devil Jalapeño Jolts $8.25
  • Experience the thrill of six tantalizing jalapeño bites, each brimming with a blend of spicy excitement and savory satisfaction. Nestled within is a molten medley of melty cheese, cocooned by our signature fresh dough that bakes to a perfect golden hue. Crafted to perfection, these devilishly delicious treats are served with a cool and creamy ranch dipper.
  • Chupacabra Cheesesteak Chunks $8.50
  • Immerse yourself in the intrigue of six savory bites, each featuring succulent steak and rich cheddar cheese, lovingly enveloped in our signature fresh dough. Baked to perfection, these morsels offer a symphony of textures and tastes that embody both indulgence and adventure. Paired with a marinara dipper.
  • Yeti's Yummy Chicken Parm Portions $8.50
  • Discover the magic of six savory bites, each a masterpiece of tender chicken and rich mozzarella cheese, lovingly enveloped in our signature fresh dough. Baked to perfection, these portions offer a symphony of taste and texture in every bite. Paired with a marinara dipper.
  • Skinwalker Slim Roll $7.25
  • Are you scared of the dark? The Skinwalker Slim Roll is the perfect companion to keep you safe. This roll includes our fresh dough wrapped around a pile of Mozzarella Shreds and Cheddar Dhreds, coated in Garlic Oil and dusted with our secret Parmesan and Garlic topping - served with a Dipperzzz of Choice!
  • Hodag Monster Roll $9.25
  • A mixture of Wisconsin and West Virginia twists! Our fresh dough is wrapped around a carnivore treat, including Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham and Mozzarella Shreds, coated in Garlic Oil, then baked and dusted with our secret Parmesan and Garlic topping - served with a Dipperzzz of Choice!
  • Thunderbird Roll $9.25
  • Whether you believe the Thunderbird is real or not, doesn't change the fact that this roll has it's own level of myth! Our fresh dough is wrapped around a sweet and smoky treat, including White Meat Chicken, Bacon, Ranch, Cheddar Shreds and Mozzarella Shreds, coated in Garlic Oil, then baked and dusted with our secret Parmesan and Garlic topping - served with a Dipperzzz of Choice!
  • Wendigo's Wicked Garlic Whirls $7.50
  • Indulge in the sinister allure of six expertly crafted garlic knots, fashioned from fresh dough and adorned with a captivating blend of garlic Parmesan seasoning. Each bite promises a whirlwind of savory satisfaction, with a perfect balance of warmth and zest that lingers on your palate. Paired with a marinara dipper.
  • Big(Foot) Breads
  • Small Cheesy Garlic Bread $8.75
  • Want to take your Garlic Breadsticks up a super notch? Let us smother it with mozzarella shreds and bake it in our flash-fire oven for that warm gooey cheese! Served with our marinara!
  • Large Cheesy Garlic Bread $12.75
  • A larger version of our famous Cheesy Garlic Bread! Want to take your Garlic Breadsticks up a super notch? Let us smother it with mozzarella shreds and bake it in our flash-fire oven for that warm gooey cheese! Served with our marinara!
  • Tomato-n-balsamic Folded Bread $6.75
  • Hand-folded Fresh Dough, Minced Garlic & Diced Tomatoes. Drizzled with Balsamic Glaze.
  • Small Garlic Bread [no Cheese] $7.75
  • The tangy, delicious garlic bread is made with our savory garlic oil, topped with our parmesan-parsley and garlic blend, and served with our marinara!
  • Large Garlic Bread [no Cheese] $11.75
  • A larger version of our famous Garlic Bread! This tangy, delicious garlic bread is made with our savory garlic oil, topped with our parmesan-parsley and garlic blend, and served with our marinara!
  • Buffalo-n-bleu Folded Bread $6.75
  • Hand-folded Fresh Dough, Buffalo Sauce, Mozzarella & Bleu Cheese. Drizzled with Buffalo Sauce.
  • Feta-n-pesto Folded Bread $6.75
  • Hand-folded Fresh Dough, Pesto Sauce, Feta and Mozzarella Shreds. Drizzled lightly with Garlic Oil.
  • Jalapeño-n-cheese Folded Bread $6.75
  • Hand-folded Fresh Dough, Alfredo Sauce, Mozzarella Shreds and Jalapeños. Drizzled with Honey Sriracha.
  • Drinks
  • 2 Liter Pepsi Products $4.50
  • Selection of 2 liter Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, or Dr. Pepper sodas.
  • Mothman's West Virginia Scream Soda (cream Soda) $3.50
  • A huge fan favorite that everyone SCREAMS for! Everyone loves Mothman and the delicious Vanilla Cream Soda within the bottle! Using only the finest vanilla for the best vanilla cream soda!
  • 16.9oz Pepsi Products $2.75
  • 16.9oz selection of Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Diet Mountain Dew, Dr. Pepper, Diet Dr. Pepper, and Brisk Iced Tea.
  • Regulär Wolpentinger Weuzelbier (root Beer) $3.50
  • Our flagship Wolpentinger Wurzelbier (Root Beer) is a favorite among cryptid followers. Our award-winning root beer has hints of vanilla, anise and honey. Available in Regulär and 0-calorie Diät.
  • Squonk (raspberry Lime Rickey Soda) $3.50
  • Our most POPULAR DRINK EVER! Our SQUONK is a unique north-eastern twist of a raspberry-lime rickey soda, or in layman's terms: a refreshing sparkling raspberry limeade! What better way to share Pennsylvania's cryptid that giving it that boost of love known as SQUONK!
  • Fresno Nightcrawler Glowing Grape Soda $3.50
  • Want a bold, fruity grape flavor? Our Fresno Nightcrawler Glowing Grape brings you the taste of summer and refreshes you from the moment you taste it! This also pairs great with Mothman's SCREAM SODA for an amazingly unique grape float!
  • Sasquatch Sarsaparilla $3.50
  • Want an old-school vibe to your next thirst quencher? Our Sasquatch Sarsaparilla is made with sassafras root extract and provides hints of licorice, caramel, vanilla and wintergreen. Get that old-school cool today!
  • Perilous Pineapple $3.50
  • RELEASE THE KRAKEN! Our unique twist on a cryptid pineapple soda focuses on an undersea Kraken adventure in your mouth! Our sweet tropical pineapple soda is made with real pineapple!
  • Snallygaster Sweet Tea $3.50
  • The tart flavor of lemon is the perfect companion for freshly brewed tea. Authentically brewed using real tea leaves and water and sweetened with real cane sugar, for an iced tea that’s, well, exactly how you’d make it.
  • Flatwoods Fantasie (orange) $3.50
  • Our orange soda is an absolute flavor burst focusing on the Flatwoods Monster from Braxton County, West Virginia. With just the right amount of sweet and tangy, our Flatwoods FANTAsie is the perfect soda for you.
  • Jersey Devil Ginger Ale $3.50
  • The Jersey Devil roams the forest of Pine Barrens, but at Cryptid Club, he continues to seek out the freshest ginger for our extremely popular ginger ale! This crisp and bubbly drink is delicious and ready for quenching your thirst!
  • 16.9 Oz Dasani Water $2.25
  • Redefine refreshment with Dasani Purified Water. Dasani is carefully crafted with a unique purification process for the purest, freshest taste.
  • Juice Box $1.50
  • Delicious, simple Apple Juice. No added sugar and 100% of the day's vitamin C in a juice box? If you won't tell the kids, we won't either.
  • Cheat River Lemon-lime $3.50
  • This citric refresher is the perfect way to quench any thirst! Lemon, lime and a hint of orange make this the best drink ever!
  • Snarly Yow Strawberry Soda $3.50
  • The ghostly Snarly Yow is here to quench your thirst! From the haunted woods of Harpers Ferry, WV and South Mountain, MD, this sweet strawberry soda is sure to keep you focused on task! The eyes of the Snarly Yow inspired this fruity treat, and we're sure you're love it!
  • Diät Wolpentinger Weuzelbier (diet Root Beer) $3.50
  • Our flagship Wolpentinger Wurzelbier (Root Beer) is a favorite among cryptid followers. Our award-winning root beer has hints of vanilla, anise and honey. Available in Regulär and 0-calorie Diät.
  • Loveland Frogman Lemonade $3.50
  • Loveland is known for its 4' Frogman that runs around on its hind legs. Cryptid Club is known for our incredible lemonade! Our lemonade is blasted full of lemon flavor and is extremely thirst-quenching! A must for any cryptid fan!
  • Limited Edition: Cryptid Cola $3.50
  • This limited edition soda combines radioactive flavors with a mysterious, mythical twist. Each bottle is infused with traces of pre-war mystique and post-apocalyptic zest, perfect for quenching the thirst of daring adventurers and curious wanderers alike.
  • Rewind And Dine
  • Your Pizza. Your Way. 13" Full Size Pizza $11.20
  • Customize YOUR PIZZA. YOUR WAY! Select your sauce, cheeses, toppings, edgers and finishes!
  • 7" Personal Pizza - Baby Mothman $8.10
  • Is our 13" Cryptid Classic Craft Pizza too big for you? NO PROBLEM! Baby-Mothman's Personal 7" Pizza is a pizza that is personalized for you! Made with in-house proofed and fresh dough, we've got you covered!
  • Baby Nessie's Personal Salad $8.10
  • A smaller approach to our GIANT salads! Start with our Lettuce Blend and then top it with the ingredients to support your personalized appetite! Served with choice of dressing packet (additional dressing packets available for an upcharge)!
  • Your Salad. Your Way. $11.20
  • Pizza not your thing? No worries! MYTHICAL PIZZA has you covered with YOUR SALAD. YOUR WAY! Pick every element of your salad build to become the greatest salad ever! Our super large salads are housed in a 64 ounce bowl, and served with dressing of your choice!
  • Extras
  • 14oz Bottle Of Mythical Pizza's Honey Sriracha $13.99
  • Elevate your dishes with our infamous Mythical Pizza's 14oz Honey Sriracha Sauce. Made with classic sriracha heat, red chili peppers, and honey sweetness, it's perfect for any occasion.
  • Dipper Of Ranch $1.50
  • This creamy and thick ranch dip is the ideal dipper for your favorite pizza!
  • Garlic Parmesan Dipper $1.50
  • This flavor-packed sauce is made with parmesan cheese, garlic, vinegar, and salt for a rich, savory taste.
  • Dipper Of Classic Marinara $1.50
  • Our Vegan-Friendly Classic Marinara is ready to be your dipper of choice!
  • Dipper Of Buffalo $1.50
  • Grab a side of the rich, buttery flavor of Buffalo! The heat is mild – but the flavor is anything but.
  • Grandioso Garlic Sauce Dipper $1.50
  • This garlic sauce provides a creamy, savory taste that is a must-have addition for your pizza!
  • Sweet Chili Dipper $1.50
  • This flavor-packed sauce is made with red chili peppers and garlic for a balanced, sweet, tart, and slightly spicy taste.
  • Mike's Hot Honey Dipper $1.50
  • Made with 100% pure honey, real chili peppers, and tangy vinegar, this product perfectly balances the floral sweetness of honey with just the right amount of chili pepper spice.
  • Dipper Of Pesto $1.50
  • Our nut-free basil pesto is the ultimate flavor dipper!
  • Dipper Of Mythical Pizza's Honey Sriracha $1.50
  • Made with classic sriracha heat, red chili peppers, and honey sweetness, it's the perfect dipper for pizza!
  • Parmesan Packet $0.08
  • Known as the King of Cheeses, with it’s buttery, fruity and nutty flavor, it is the perfect complement to every slice.
  • Garlic Packet $0.08
  • The unique, distinct pungent aroma and flavor pairs perfectly with any style pizza.
  • 12oz Bottle Of Mike's Hot Honey $13.99
  • Mike's Hot Honey is the original honey infused with chilies, a flavor combination of two of nature's most unique and delicious foods to drizzle on all your favorite foods.
  • Dipper Of Balsamic Glaze $1.50
  • This acidic, velvety liquid is a delicious add-on for any pizza or salad!
  • Crushed Red Pepper Packet $0.08
  • Our fiery red flakes will add heat to any pizza, giving it that bite you crave.
  • Oregano Packet $0.08
  • The aromatic, warm, slightly bitter taste is recognizable anywhere.
  • Italian Spice Packet $0.08
  • A classic combination of oregano, basil, marjoram, garlic, thyme, savory and a dash of crushed red pepper for that extra kick.
  • Dressing Packet $1.00
  • Want to "dress" things up? Be it your salad, or your pizza, we're sure we have that right addition for your meal!
  • Dipper Of Barbecue Sauce $1.50
  • This deliciously thick and tangy-sweet barbecue adds a level of smokiness to any pizza!
  • Slices & Combos
  • Individual Slices $2.25
  • Choose From Mozzarella Monster (Cheese), Yeti's Pepperoni Pie (Pepperoni) or our Mothman's Meaty Treat (Pepperoni, Ham & Sausage)
  • Mega Munch Meal $6.00
  • TWO slices of our famous pizza and a 16.9oz Pepsi product for only $6! Available all day, every day!
  • Desserts
  • Chocolate Chip Brownie $3.00
  • These decadent brownies are the best ending to any meal! These brownies feature a dense, fudgey texture, and are topped with sweet chocolate morsels for the ultimate chocolate flavor rush!
  • Salted Caramel Monster Cookie $3.00
  • Talk about a decadent treat! This brown-sugar based dough accented with flakes of pure sea salt and generous amounts of creamy caramel and buttery HEATH toffee bits covered in milk chocolate.
  • Chocolate Chip Monster Cookie $3.00
  • Our 1/4 lb. MONSTER COOKIES are baked fresh at MYTHICAL PIZZA every day! Nothing completes your meal like one of these delicious treats!
  • Ginger Molasses Monster Cookie $2.00
  • Fall (get it?) in love with our tender, chewy molasses cookie with sweet spices of cinnamon and nutmeg and complimenting flavor of ginger and meticulously topped with sugar crystals!
  • Chocolate Chip Cannoli $4.00
  • Our cannolis are out of this world! Our shells have a light, flaky consistency that complements our delicious cream, which is combined with citron pieces, chocolate chips, vanilla, and cinnamon for a sweet, traditional flavor.
  • New York Style Cheesecake $3.50
  • Our cheesecake has a rich, velvety smooth consistency! Each cheesecake is made with soft cheese, eggs, and sugar in the famous New York style of cheesecakes with a light graham cracker crust.
  • Utensils & Napkins
  • Paper Plates $0.05
  • Plastic Knife & Fork Set $0.05
  • Extra Napkins $0.05
Check out other Pizza Places in Berkeley Springs.


Similiar Restaurants Nearby:

West Virginia Restaurant Guide: See Menus, Ratings and Reviews for Restaurants in West Virginia
United States Restaurant Guide:
AK | AL | AR | AZ | CA | CT | CO | DE | FL | GA | HI | ID | IL | IN | IA | KS | KY | LA | MD | ME | MA | MI | MN | MS | MO | MT | NC | ND | NE | NV | NH | NJ | NM | NY | OH | OK | OR | PA | RI | SC | SD | TN | TX | UT | VT | VA | WA | WV | WI | WY
Canadian Major Cities and Provinces:
Alberta | British Columbia | Manitoba | New Brunswick | Newfoundland | Nova Scotia | Ontario | Prince Edward Island | Quebec | Saskatchewan | Yukon | Calgary | Edmonton | Montreal | Ottawa | Regina | Saskatoon | Toronto | Vancouver | Victoria | Winnipeg |
Most Popular US City Guides:
Albuquerque | Amherst | Atlanta | Austin | Baltimore | Boston | Boulder | Brooklyn | Burlington | Cape Cod | Charlotte | Charleston | Chicago | Cincinnati | Cleveland | Columbus | Dallas / Fort Worth | Denver | Detroit | El Paso | Flagstaff | Fort Lauderdale | Fresno | Gulf Coast | Hartford | Hoboken | Honolulu | Houston | Indianapolis | Jackson | Jacksonville | Jersey City | Kansas City | Knoxville | Las Vegas | Long Island | Los Angeles | Louisville | Lowell | Madison | Memphis | Miami | Milwaukee | Minneapolis | Myrtle Beach | Nashua | Nashville | New Orleans | New York City | Oakland | Oklahoma City | Omaha | Orange County | Orlando | Philadelphia | Phoenix | Pittsburgh | Portland | Providence | Raleigh | Reno | Richmond | Riverside | Sacramento | Saint Louis | Salem | Salt Lake City | San Antonio | San Diego | San Francisco | San Jose | Santa Barbara | Santa Fe | Seattle | St. Paul | Tampa | Tucson | Tulsa | Twin Cities | Virginia Beach | Washington, DC | Wilmington | Winston-Salem