Titus Pastry Shoppe

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

820 W South St
Lebanon, IN 46052

Phone: (765) 482-1740

Website

Neighborhood: Lebanon

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

All products made the old fashion way!
Originating in the 1950’s, Titus Bakery is a third-generation, family-owned busines...s that has earned a reputation for providing some of the finest donuts and pastries in the State. The recipes and processes developed over this time provide today’s customers with not only consistent quality, but a tantalizingly wide selection of tasty treats. Recently Titus has expanded its offerings to include home-made pies and cakes as well as a delicatessen items featuring Boar’s Head meats and cheeses, sold in our four signature sandwiches or by the pound. Whether you join us for a leisurely lunch or choose our convenient drive-thru, we think you’ll be back for more. Coming To Westfield in 2016!

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Titus Pastry Shoppe

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Titus Pastry Shoppe

Write a Review

  4.6 stars - Based on 72 votes

#3 out of 59 restaurants in Lebanon

#1 of 3 Bakery in Lebanon

5 star				56 votes	78%
4 star				10 votes	14%
3 star				1 votes	1%
2 star				1 votes	1%
1 star				4 votes	6%

Top Reviews of Titus Pastry Shoppe

04/21/2024 - MenuPix User

02/02/2024 - MenuPix User

12/30/2023 - MenuPix User

12/19/2023 - MenuPix User

12/08/2023 - MenuPix User

09/24/2023 - MenuPix User
Awesome donuts especially the black forest

06/01/2023 - Nicole
Nothing else compares to Titus! And their coconut cream doughnut is amazing 🤩

05/17/2022 - MenuPix User
Best donuts in Indiana!

04/28/2022 - Terri
Hour and a half drive but sooooo worth it!! Staff and donuts are amazing!! The Pershing coffee OMG!!!!

11/01/2020 - Barb
I can not express enough how amazing these cakes was . We ordered 3 different cakes 3 different sizes . They all was exactly what we wanted ! Absolutely beautiful colored ( was for a Halloween wedding ) and everyone raved how wonderful they tasted . I wish I could post a pic of how beautiful they looked . Thank you Titus !!!

08/07/2020 - Dave Snow
This place is the pride of Lebanon’s culinary scene. They’ve recently expanded locations and their product line but their donut quality has not suffered, that is THE reason to patronize Titus!

08/01/2020 - MenuPix User
Always good and fresh!

06/17/2020 - MenuPix User
Best donuts in the world. Love the Bismark. They also carry local honey.

04/23/2020 - Doodle Mom
Titus donuts are AMAZING! There are so many varieties to choose from and everything we've tried has always been delicious! This is also a company that gives back to the community. They donated over 200 donuts for our school fundraiser. Best donuts in Indiana!

09/21/2019 - JenniferB
Luscious goodies, fantastic service. Highly recommend the apple fritters.

06/06/2019 - MenuPix User
Good donuts but high prices compared to Longs or Hilligoss.

05/15/2019 - Boone County girl
Fabulous ~

03/11/2019 - MenuPix User
Delicious pastries. Highly recommend

09/22/2018 - Lianne
I don’t even like donuts but if I’m going to eat one it’s gotta be from here! They’re most famous for their pershings (delicious!) but my personal favorite is the chocolate-covered Bismark! I don’t know about anything else because that’s all I ever get!!

07/30/2018 - Victoria Z.
Titus is a lovely bakery with a huge selection and amazing donuts and coffee.

10/23/2016 - Charlie
Best bakery I've ever been too! The staff was extremely friendly and the sandwiches were great! The bread is homemade and the meat is high quality. I will definitely visit this bakery again!

10/15/2016 - Soccer mom
I heard such good things about this place but I was dissappionted. We bought lunch for five people everyone got a sub and four out five were undercooked. They were flat and doughy. We had stopped in between soccer games and I didn't have time to complain. I was really looking forward to having an option that was not a national chain!!!!!

08/06/2016 - Phil
Worth the drive! Best donuts I have ever eaten!!

07/22/2016 - Russell
Just visited your new Westfield location. You've got to be kidding me. You call this a pastry shop. Seven pastries for $11.44. I don't mind paying that much if I get that much. The turnovers were flat and hard, looks like they didn't get a full second rising. The fillings didn't taste any better than pie filling out of the can. The chocolate custard filled were tough, looks like they didn't get their second rising also. The chocolate frosting was tasty, looks like it was put on by a monkey using a paintbrush. A lot of hip and a lot of price for nothing.

06/06/2016 - Rob Smith
I rate this bakery as average...nothing exceptional.
Nothing here that I would go out of my way for.
Passing through Lebanon today... Saw the bakery stopped.
One yeast donut, 3 Maple (1 filled1 not) saved the Danish and turnover til later. All were typical except the cherry turnover which when I bit into it was nothing but air...an open cavity with a thin layer of cherry syrup and not even a single cherry.
Nice place, nice people.... Nothing special

05/14/2016 - Kayla
My family used to live in Lebanon, now we live in Virginia. Every time someone in the family goes out to Indiana, we have to get some. We have been eating Titus Pastry donuts for over 20 years. They are hands down the best donuts on the planet!

07/24/2015 - Don
These donuts are amazing. Very friendly workers who were helpful when we had some questions.

07/07/2015 - Christine
If you don't like Titus your nuts. A hidden gem in Indiana. Great product for a great price. Definitely worth the drive.

06/24/2015 - Whitney
I have been there 10+ times and not impressed. not only as a customer service far from being top notch, I also got an item there a little while back that was a shortbread cookie, which is something I love and normally eat a lot. I could not buy into it and neither could my two children. so I brought this to their attention and the manager or owner lady came out to my table and said well I had one today and I thought it was just fine and walked off. Did not ask me if I would like something different or anything she basically just said that I was an idiot. This is only the beginning of the bad service that I have received their their donuts are pretty good I would definitely not say the greatest however the service makes the donuts just mediocre when you have to deal with people like that.

04/13/2015 - eve long
While I was dining in the bakery the other day I could not help but over hear a conversation that was being played out in the drive thru. T here was a young lady requesting nuts on some dough nut and the employee was down right nasty, saying that she could not put nuts on the dough nut in question, when the woman asked for another employee, the employee who was helping her told her no one was there to help but her. as the conversation went on it sounded like this was done in the past by everyone that had worked there before even the owner her self and other family members. this sound like a refusal to wait on her!!!!!! WHO CARES IF THE DOUGH NUT IN QUESTION WAS A SIGNATURE DOUGH NUT OR NOT SOME PEOPLE LIKE DIFFERENT TASTES . TEXTURES AN SO ON. If your going to so picky about your produced then maybe your in the wrong business. ALL CHEFS LIKE CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM. WE ARE ALL DIFFERENT!!! EMBARRASS IT!! All so on the same subject she was willing to pay an up charge.

05/07/2014 - Terrbear1973
Love this bakery! It just keeps getting better every time I stop by. Great fresh donuts! Try the Bacon Maple Bismarks... Absolutely wonderful.