18 Bay Restaurant

4.7

23 reviews

#6 out of 16 restaurants in Shelter Island

($$$), Italian
Hours today: 5:00pm-9:30pm

Add Review

Call

Website

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

23 N Ferry Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964

Phone: (631) 749-0053

Website

Neighborhood: Shelter Island

Update Listing

Bookmark Update Menus Edit Info Read Reviews Write Review

Hours

Open Today:

5:00pm-9:30pm
Monday5:00pm-9:30pm
TuesdayClosed
Wednesday5:00pm-9:30pm
Thursday5:00pm-9:30pm
Friday5:00pm-10:30pm
Saturday5:00pm-10:30pm
Sunday5:00pm-9:00pm

Update Hours

View the Menu

View Menus

Restaurant Details

Delivery
No

Payment
Credit Cards Accepted

Parking
Parking Lot

Good for Kids
No

Attire
Dressy

Alcohol
Full Bar

Reservations
Yes

Cuisines:
Italian

Price Point
$$$

WiFi
Yes

Outdoor Seats
Yes

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

See Menus

Write a Review for 18 Bay Restaurant

Reviews for 18 Bay Restaurant

Write a Review

4.7 stars - Based on 23 reviews

#6 out of 16 restaurants in Shelter Island

#1 of 2 Italian in Shelter Island

5 star	17 reviews	74%
4 star	5 reviews	22%
3 star	1 review	4%
2 star	0 reviews	0%
1 star	0 reviews	0%

Top Reviews of 18 Bay Restaurant

07/14/2024 - Carlos M.
ok

06/16/2024 - Eileen C.
I went to 18 Bay with my family for a celebratory dinner two weekends ago. The food was absolutely delicious, especially the Cacio e Pepe pasta. The owner was really nice and made sure to have a genuine conversation with us and all the other guests. The menu changes often, so I'm already thinking about going back.

Best Menus of Shelter Island Best Menus of Long Island

Italian Restaurants in Shelter Island

Planet Bliss ($$)
American
Distance: 0.02 miles

Kyle's ($$)
Bakery, Bar, Diner, Breakfast
Distance: 0.03 miles

Shelter Island Slice ($)
Pizza, Sandwiches
Distance: 0.20 miles

Bella Vita Pizza ($$)
Pizza
Distance: 0.30 miles

Shelter Island Craft Brewery ($$)
Breweries
Distance: 0.32 miles

Vine Street Cafe ($$$)
Cafe, Sandwiches, American New, Italian, Asian Fusion

Leon 1909 ($)
Italian, French

Vine Street Cafe ($$$)
Cafe, Sandwiches, American New, Italian, Asian Fusion

Salt Waterfront Bar & Grill ($$)
American, Gastropubs, Bar Food

Hero Haven & More (Shirley, NY)

After a disappointing experience some time ago, I returned today for fresh bagels and was warmly greeted by the friendly owner in a clean and welcomin... see review

Wine Cellar on Main (Northport, NY)

The wine bar offers a welcoming atmosphere with live music on weekend nights, a variety of quality wines, and tasty small plates, making it suitable f... see review

Caffe Catania Pizzeria (Commack, NY)

The flavors here dance on the palate with an exquisite balance of freshness and boldness, creating a truly memorable dining experience. Each bite reve... see review

Bagel Boss East (Bay Shore, NY)

The bagels here are always fresh, warm, and delicious, making it a perfect stop during an early morning commute or weekend outing despite the busy, so... see review

The Shipyard (Greenport, NY)

This restaurant has some of the best food I've had in a long time, and the vibe is super chill. The staff were friendly and attentive, making the whol... see review

View Menus

18 Bay Restaurant
Home
Long Island
Long Island
Shelter Island

Long Island Restaurant Guide: See Menus, Ratings and Reviews for Restaurants in Long Island and New York

United States Restaurant Guide:

AK | AL | AR | AZ | CA | CT | CO | DE | FL | GA | HI | ID | IL | IN | IA | KS | KY | LA | MD | ME | MA | MI | MN | MS | MO | MT | NC | ND | NE | NV | NH | NJ | NM | NY | OH | OK | OR | PA | RI | SC | SD | TN | TX | UT | VT | VA | WA | WV | WI | WY

Canadian Major Cities and Provinces:

Most Popular US City Guides:

18 Bay Restaurant

Location and Contact

Hours

View the Menu

Restaurant Details

Restaurant Description

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for 18 Bay Restaurant

Reviews for 18 Bay Restaurant

Top Reviews of 18 Bay Restaurant

Best Restaurants Nearby

Nearby Restaurants

Menus People Viewed Nearby

Recent Restaurant Reviews

18 Bay Restaurant

Location and Contact

Hours

View the Menu

Restaurant Details

Restaurant Description

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for 18 Bay Restaurant

Reviews for 18 Bay Restaurant

Top Reviews of 18 Bay Restaurant

Best Restaurants Nearby

Nearby Restaurants

Menus People Viewed Nearby

Recent Restaurant Reviews

Oops, we can't find your location