Main Street Pizza Co
Add Your Vote!
Menus People Viewed Nearby
Batavia's Original Pizzeria ($$)
Big Pauly's Pizza ($)
Ficarella's Pizzeria ($)
Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
Alex's Place ($$)
American, Steakhouse, Seafood
Additional Dining Info
Credit Cards Accepted
Good for Kids
Beer and Wine
$ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
Mon-Thu: 11am - 11pm, Fri-Sat: 11am - 12am, Sun: 11am - 11pm
Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.
| Add Photo
Top Reviews of Main Street Pizza Co
07/07/2017 - Linda Forman
I ordered 2 dozen wings and picked them up. I live outside of Batavia. When I got home I checked and they were wrong. I called and they said they would replace them with the right ones. No one offered to deliver so I wouldn't have to go back to Batavia or not even a discount on my next purchase. Great pizza and wings but very poor customer service. I haven't been back since. I feel they did not care that I was inconvenienced.
01/25/2015 - firstname.lastname@example.org
on saturday the 24th i ordered pizza and wings for 2pm. they were ready at 2pm,no complaints. on getting home 15-18 minutes later i found the pizza stone cold and the wings luke warm. i do know the food will cool off some coming home but the car was heated up. when i called to complain some i was told it was my fault for having it in the car too long. i wasnt asking for anything just letting them know that the pizza was probably made early and started to cool down before i even picked them up. the employee was very rude to me and when i told him there were other places in batavia he hung up on me. its too bad because i like main street pizza and i really havent been going anywhere else for the past 2 years or so. what really bothered me was how the employee treated me. its repeat customers that keeps restaurants going. you have lost one of them and i guarantee you will lose more with employees like that. cold food is 1 thing, rude behavior is another
10/27/2014 - Jeff
I called in an order of 3 chicken finger subs from home in Byron, Which is 15 minutes from Main Street Pizza in Batavia, NY. The girl on the phone told me the subs would be ready in 20 minutes. When i got there 25 minutes later ( Because i had to stop to get gas for my car ) The subs were still not ready, But told me the subs would be right out in a few minutes. Well, I ended up waiting there 40 more minutes , Making it one hour and 5 minutes for them to make 3 subs. When she brought the subs out to me, She never said she was sorry for making me wait or anything. When i got home, The large chicken finger subs only had 3 thin chicken fingers on them with tons of lettuce to make it look thick. I called back to complain , But was hung up on.. WELL ! It's needless to say I'll never go there again.
12/16/2010 - Ken Jablonicky
Worth taking the ride from Orchard Park to pick up the best pizza in WNY Chicago deep dish and meat lovers pizza out of this work
Recent Restaurant Reviews
I eat at the poke a dot three or more times a week it's the best it beats the fish sticks I eat on the other days go poke a dot...
Big Pauly's Pizza
I've always loved there jumbo chicken wings but..... this time so disappointed number 1 they weren't jumbo 2 over cooked I think it's time to change t...
John & Mary's
Loved it! Just a good place to eat! Had a Royal sub, so good. Nice toasted roll, and the sausage was delicious! The atmosphere was fun, lots of mo...
Bergen Farm Market Family Restaurant
I was here once for a dinner. The food was acceptable. The service was fantastic....
Willow Bend Inn
Good food awesome bands every Saturday ...