Batavia's Original Pizzeria

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

500 E Main St
Batavia, NY 14020

Phone: (585) 343-3303

Website

Neighborhood: Batavia

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Batavia's Original Pizzeria

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Batavia's Original Pizzeria

Write a Review

  3.8 stars - Based on 37 reviews

#6 out of 90 restaurants in Batavia

#2 of 9 Pizza in Batavia

5 star				8 reviews	22%
4 star				19 reviews	51%
3 star				7 reviews	19%
2 star				1 review	3%
1 star				2 reviews	5%

Top Reviews of Batavia's Original Pizzeria

08/25/2024 - Michael J.
Had dinner with friends at this pizza joint on a double date. The guys went for personal pizzas, while the girls opted for salads - all delicious. The server was super attentive, even when we stayed past closing time without any pressure to leave. This OG pizzeria is a local gem with a rich history and a menu full of tasty options, from pasta to subs to pizza, all in a family-friendly atmosphere.

06/13/2024 - Demi G.
Good Food

01/16/2021 - Tim
Been coming to this location since 1953. It's a shame when you Order a large sub and when you come to pickup your order you get a large pizza with just cheese, mushrooms on dough? Then when I wait for the correct order to be made, it ended up being wrong when I got home?! Plus they wanted me to take the pizza as well?? Who in hell is going to mushrooms, dough and cheese?
Third order in a month and half that has been wrong and I have not complained, but finslky has to say something! Seems like no real supervision with these young folks. Have heard a lot of consumer negativity lately.. Know times are really tough but you can't get repeat business with these standards... Sorry, always loved the product but! Miss the old times..

08/22/2020 - Karen kelly
Worst meal in a long time!! We went to Arby's after a very disappointing meal

08/22/2020 - Karen kelly
Follow up. We like lemon with our water and fish. Batavia's Original was out of lemon at 7:00pm on Friday. So I ordered a Greek personal pizza, well it came out without Feta cheese and artichokes for which I ordered. They were out of feta and artichokes, they put green peppers on my pizza, that I did not order. like I wouldn't notice!!! The steak sub was a steak-Ulm's, really I gave them to my 6yr old son 25 years ago. Worst meal ever. The server Dudu not come back but the "manager on duty did". Will not return