Reviews for Mystic Muffin

08/09/2025 - Matthew L.
The ordering process was a bit confusing at first since the owners gauge how many bagels to toast before individuals order their toppings, but the owners were very helpful and friendly throughout. I enjoyed a ham and cheese bagel paired with their famous apple cake and coffee, and the apple cake, with its moist texture, crisp edges, and soft apple chunks, was especially memorable.

10/20/2024 - Kirstin N.
The ordering process at this charming establishment was initially a bit confusing, with bagels being toasted based on the group's needs before individual orders were taken. The owners were incredibly friendly and accommodating, making the experience enjoyable. The cozy interior, with limited seating, created a bustling, community feel, especially during busy mornings.

04/21/2024 - MZ S.
Love your food!