Reviews for Benny's Big Time Pizzeria

08/27/2021 - MenuPix User
Good food - friendly service and a fun atmosphere

02/24/2021 - Blaire J
My boyfriend and I ordered Tony's Pepperoni 🍕 from Benny's last night because it's the best pepperoni pizza we've ever had and we're hooked on it. It's like the Britt's donut of pepperoni pizzas. Britt's donut has become the only glazed donut I want to eat, and the same is true of Benny's Tony Pepperoni. I'm not usually a pepperoni fan, but the quality of the pepperoni and the other ingredients is as fresh and flavorful as it gets. The pepperoni is always super generous, covering the pizza, and flame kissed to crisped perfection. The fresh mozzarella, homemade red sauce and the wood fired crust come together to make it our favorite pepperoni pizza on the planet. I'm hooked on drizzling it with Benny's Hot Honey. We've ordered their pizza 3 times in the past 6 months and every time it has been just as delicious. And lucky us, we have pizza leftovers for lunch! My boyfriend recently ordered a pepperoni from Domino's and the quality of the pepperoni was awful, and the Domino's pepperoni was swimming in grease. (The pepperoni was probably about to go bad, but we're not taking that chance again.) When we're craving pepperoni pizza, we order Benny's. The shiitake is another favorite of mine. Exquisite. Want to try a flavor bomb? The Chicken Parmesan was just that. Wicked good & unlike any Chicken Parmesan we've ever had.

02/05/2021 - MenuPix User
Love their pizzas and salads

01/31/2021 - Tony G
The worst pizza in Wilmington. I had high expectations for this place based on the reviews. Must be employee and friends reviews. Sauce tasted like paste straight from the can, cheese almost flavorless and raw dough need I say more. Tried to eat one piece and couldn't finish.